3 ms·
You're thinking in modern terms of energy, force and physics, but the past, as they say, was a foreign country. People back then didn't recognize any distinctio
by krapp 5y ago
You're thinking in modern terms of energy, force and physics, but the past, as they say, was a foreign country. People back then didn't recognize any distinction between what we would consider natural and supernatural order. They took for granted that they lived in a world deeply influenced by spirits, angels, devils and deities, with hidden hands behind everything. If you believed that God literally spoke the universe into being, then it was simply self-evident that words and symbols could have magical effects.
Add cognitive bias and placebo effects to that worldview, and as far as the medieval mind was concerned, it makes more sense to believe in magic then to doubt it, because sometimes it seemed to work. Magical thinking persists to this day for the same reason - it provides a false but shockingly self-sustaining model of reality.
If you're curious about this from a scholarly point of view, here[0] is a talk by Dr. Irving Finkel about ghost stories recorded in ancient Assyrian cuneiform, which touches on some of the magical practices involved, and I'd also recommend the Esoterica[1] channel which discusses the various kinds of magical philosophy by studying ancient magical texts. You can get a good idea of the way such people thought and how they saw the world from studying their writing.
[0]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zNNaZ110ee4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zNNaZ110ee4
[1]https://www.youtube.com/c/ESOTERICAchannel/videos https://www.youtube.com/c/ESOTERICAchannel/videos