3 ms·
> The misunderstandings around this drug stem from misunderstandings of basic statistics and the scientific method So I agree with your post both in letter of
by roenxi 5y ago
> The misunderstandings around this drug stem from misunderstandings of basic statistics and the scientific method
So I agree with your post both in letter of what is written and in spirit, but...
The misunderstandings around this drug also stem from the fact that its detractors were unhinged and anti-scientific. They were dismissing a large, obvious statistical effect without any argument. The publicised pushback around Joe Rogan was spearheaded by people who thought the problem was that Ivermectin is effective in horses.
I'm perfectly happy to pick this hill to argue on - the people who had hope that Ivermectin helped were the sort of people who are persuaded by evidence. It was never strong evidence, but the balance was in favour of Ivermectin for a while there for people who only looked at studies and hadn't had their attention drawn to the endemic parasite thing.
- eightysixfour 5y ago> The misunderstandings around this drug also stem from the fact that its detractors were unhinged and anti-scientific. They were dismissing a large, obvious statistical effect without any argument. No. The extreme pushback started after higher quality studies came out that showed there was no effect and those swayed by the initial Brazilian data wouldn’t let it go. For some segment of the population it became a magical COVID cure and any high quality studies were just big pharma ignoring cheap solutions so they could make more money.
- gadders 5y agoNo. The extreme pushback started when Donald Trump mentioned it.
- SamBam 5y agoI think that's right but not complete. I think the biggest pushback came from the notion that a large segment of the population appeared to be against the scientific consensus on Covid, contemptuous about risk mitigation strategies, skeptical/fear-mongering about the vaccines, and pushing conspiracy theories, and then these were the who turned around and said there's a great drug that works miracles against Covid and the government doesn't want you to have it. Now, this may not be an accurate representation of all those who were talking about ivermectin, but they were the most prominent voices -- the "do your research" types. The bias that this produced in others against even considering ivermectin was strictly irrational, of course, since it was against the sources and not about studies, but, that said, many of these same people had been pushing hydroxychloroquine, massive vitamins C injections, and urine therapy, all without evidence. The underlying desire for ivermectin to be real seemed (at least from the outside) to stem more from discovering some cheap secret weapon that "the scientific community" didn't want them to know about.
- FeepingCreature 5y agoYeah but the problem is that every time this happens, the inevitable pushback ends up validating all their fears, whether or not the secret weapon is real. The whole system evolves towards bipolarity, where things that split society into two halves are amplified. That's why all the moderates only see extremists on the other side.
- 7sidedmarble 5y agoNow I'm not sure if this mechanism of helping secondary parasite infections was understood at the time of the initial 'buzz' by researchers. I'm sure at least some of them had a pretty good idea. Regardless, what I remember the initial scuffle being about was that some people wanted to go out and try ivermectin before any good studies had been done to confirm these earlier hopes. That doesn't sound very scientific to me. It sounds desperate. You can argue Ivermectin might have a good enough safety profile to have warranted experimenting on yourself. And I tend to err on the side of trusting people to understand a little about taking their healthcare into their own hands. That said, it's not exactly how medical professionals see things. And people did get poisoned here and there after all. The average person doesn't know how to self administer medicine. I think this is why the 'worth a shot' opinion on ivermectin wasn't a great idea and it wasn't because the people excited about it were better persuaded by facts and logic.