7 ms·
This article is a fairly valueless press release for Dice, but be that as it may: there are no shortages for developers, there are only shortages for developers
by patio11 15y ago
This article is a fairly valueless press release for Dice, but be that as it may: there are no shortages for developers, there are only shortages for developers at the wages employers are willing to pay.
- mey 15y agoIn addition to being unable to pay what the market demands, companies (from my anecdotal perspective) also don't have any desire to train new developers into positions.
- thematt 15y agoIt's not that they're unable to pay -- they choose not to. I see so many companies that want something for nothing. They want the automation and savings from the systems that developers are building, they're just not willing to pay for it. But then ask them if they'd rather go back to the manual business process they were doing before (that doesn't require paying developer salaries) and they look at you like you're crazy.
- euroclydon 15y agoPart of the problem, for these .NET and Java jobs, is the job itself, not necessarily the pay. I get a half dozen calls per week for crappy internal .NET SharePointy positions at near the same salary I'm making. I wouldn't want to do those jobs for 150% of the salary. Folks that like to program, usually don't like to write back office apps.
- ghurlman 15y agoThat's part of the problem... a good chunk of the .Net shortage is a SharePoint developer shortage... real, actual developers, not draggy-droppy ones. Developers with a good head on their shoulders can get 6 figures easy doing SharePoint... but who in God's name would want to?
- mgutz 15y agoHeck, I took a big pay cut to be happier. I was a .NET enterprise developer in the six figures. There is something about building things outside the box instead of being part of an assembly line at corporate shops. The lack of politics and endless meetings is a bonus too. It's not always about the money.
- dos1 15y agoThis thread is indicative of the bias I see on HN. .Net and Java are "uncool" and therefore must not be suited for solving real world problems or doing interesting things. They are also often synonymous with bloated corporate bureaucracies and meetings. By these same stereotypes, should I assume that every Ruby developer is living in a party house with his 4 other co-founders, eating ramen and making social networking applications?
- euroclydon 15y agoWrong. Four words: "Nature of the work"
- georgieporgie 15y ago.Net and Java are "uncool" I think he was saying that the typical Enterprise jobs are uncool, not that .Net is necessarily so.
- droithomme 15y agoIt's not bias, it's just a realistic observation of the market forces at work. People are willing to put up with bureaucracy and dull projects for more pay. There is no shortage of talent, there is merely an abundance of employers who are not realistic about market rates.
- phillmv 15y agoUntil recently those were the only situations in which you could get a job as a Ruby developer – hamming it out on your own, in a small startup or at a consultancy. It's still hard to get an Enterprise job as a Ruby developer. Hence the stereotype.
- patio11 15y agoThere is probably a number at which you or I would write back office apps, though. People don't do I-banking out of love, and there is a lot of headroom between well-paid devs and them. I kinda like my job right now but for a million bucks I'd kinda like your Sharepoint installation, too.
- blacksmythe 15y agoThis seems to sum up the article (and your response) pretty well: "Why the shortage? ....NET developers earn around $83,000 per year, but Java developers typically make more than $91,000."
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- euroclydon 15y agoIt's not the eight thousand dollars. Trust me. Most schools teach OO in Java. HR departments and often times hiring managers just play keyword bingo. A good developer who knows Java will pick up C# just fine. Java, and it's ecosystem, are a little more difficult to use and master than C#, and IMO, warrant the extra average pay.
- dos1 15y agoI believe it's the other way around. C# is much more difficult to master than Java in my opinion. You have reified generics in C#, there's true lambda expressions, the dynamic keyword, named arguments, p/invoke etc. Many of these things make the language more expressive and powerful in my opinion, but also give it a much steeper learning curve to truly master.
- eropple 15y agoJava is a little more difficult to practically use because it lacks most of that. Writing clean, maintainable code in Java is a lot harder (for me, at least) than the same in C# (or even in Scala, and Scala seems to lend itself naturally to writing a mess). Also, let's be honest: the Java ecosystem is a mess in a lot of ways. One of the biggest pluses to the .NET world is that things tend to Just Work a lot more than in the Java world. Not that this is a huge deal (I work in Java, and handle it fine), but considerably more knowledge of the entire Java stack is often necessary than on .NET.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoI'm not sure those figures tell you much. Java and .NET jobs tend to be in different parts of the country depending on the culture of the city. .NET jobs are concentrated in the east, where cost of living is much lower, and Java jobs are more concentrated in the west.
- rbanffy 15y agoIt seems the enterprisey .NET shops interviewed already hired all the crappy .NET developers who are willing to work for that kind of money and now they would have to move to more expensive ones than the ones they had before. Their reluctance is easy to explain. Programmers are interesting animals - the good ones work for fun. As long as their bills are getting paid and work is interesting, they stay. Give them a brain-dead job, like anything Sharepoint-related, and they leave.
- kenjackson 15y agoProgrammers are interesting animals - the good ones work for fun. As long as their bills are getting paid and work is interesting, they stay. I disgaree. They do work on interesting stuff, but getting bills paid isn't sufficient. There's no shortage of interesting work. If you can't find an interesting job at pay you find compelling then there's a problem.
- mgkimsal 15y agoMaybe there's a problem in my situation then. I've not yet found a job that was both interesting with "compelling" pay. Good pay, often yes. "Good" meaning I could pay my bills and have a decent life. But that's not "compelling" to me. I'm not expecting "fuck you" money, but something that pays enough to compel me to be in a car for 2-3 hours per day commuting, or something interesting enough to compel me to move states. We probably have different numbers for "compelling" pay.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- roel_v 15y ago"Programmers are interesting animals - the good ones work for fun. As long as their bills are getting paid and work is interesting, they stay." LOL. Only the idiots. The others find places where they get to do stuff they love and where they get paid well.
- suivix 15y ago
- StrawberryFrog 15y agoGood developers are hard to find at any price.
- CWuestefeld 15y agoPatrick, this is almost a tautology. The statement is true about pretty much any commodity, in the absence of rationing.
- earl 15y agoPut another way, employers hope that whining instead of paying the market clearing wage will find employees.