4 ms·
The notion of paying people to drive the speed limit (with money taken from speeding ticket fines) reminded me of the daycare late charge experiments. [1] These
by gnicholas 5y ago
The notion of paying people to drive the speed limit (with money taken from speeding ticket fines) reminded me of the daycare late charge experiments. [1] These showed that when daycares started charging late fees to parents who were picking up kids late, parents became less timely. Apparently the fees transformed the transaction into a financial one, and parents felt that they could pick up later because they were paying for it.
I could imagine a similar thing happening with this type of financial system for drivers. People might drive slower sometimes, but figure it's OK to speed other times because the whole system is financially-mediated.
1: https://freakonomics.com/2013/10/what-makes-people-do-what-they-do/ https://freakonomics.com/2013/10/what-makes-people-do-what-t...
FWIW, I have no idea if anyone has tried, succeeded, or failed to replicate these experiments.
- stubish 5y agoIt doesn't work that way with speed cameras here. Repeated offenses will get your license revoked, at which point your offenses start being driving without a license and speeding which will end in jail.
- akvadrako 5y agoThat sounds okay though as long as the fee is correctly set. Its likely that at any decent sized daycare one of the employees would be willing to do overtime each day.
- kmos17 5y agoNot what happened in that experiment, it’s in the article: “Over the initial three-day trial, almost 25,000 cars were caught on camera, according to the YouTube video. The average speed of cars travelling through the school zone was reduced from 32km/h before the trial to 25km/h during the experiment.” Enforcement of fines plus the possibility of losing one’s license i think would be enough to ensure the effectiveness, but maybe also displaying each driver’s speed visibly is a factor? In fact I imagine for the daycare experiment if they had combined fines + the possibility of having ones child dismissed from the program it also would have been more effective.