11 ms·
Nearly everyone drives at a safe speed, regardless of what the posted speed limit is (both over and under). I can't even recall witnessing insanely dangerous d
by WalterBright 5y ago
Nearly everyone drives at a safe speed, regardless of what the posted speed limit is (both over and under).
I can't even recall witnessing insanely dangerous driving, outside of someone clearly impaired.
It speeding laws were removed (except for children zones), I doubt you'd see any difference.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- standardUser 5y agoI see people weaving in and out of lanes on a regular basis when I drive in California, usually at a much higher speed than other cars. Where do you drive that you don't often see dangerous driving?
- sokoloff 5y agoI see people doing that as well; most of the time what I see isn’t actually dangerous; it’s mildly annoying but objectively does not appear to be dangerous.
- standardUser 5y agoObjectively speaking, driving is the most dangerous thing most of us will ever do in our lives. Though it is debatable which behaviors cause more injury and death, I would argue that any behavior that surprises other drivers is something we should work to deter. And we all know that the higher the speed, the greater risk of injury an death.
- WalterBright 5y ago> And we all know that the higher the speed, the greater risk of injury an death. It's not that simple. Driving on city streets, at lower speeds, has higher accident and fatality rates. Increasing the speed limit on highways actually reduced fatalities because more people would eschew the city streets for the freeways. Personally, driving 55 was always lulling me to sleep. I was always stopping at McD's for coffee, or the rest stops so I could run a lap or so. Driving faster keeps me awake and alert. BTW, I'm not proposing legalizing reckless driving.
- standardUser 5y ago"Increasing the speed limit on highways actually reduced fatalities because more people would eschew the city streets for the freeways." That sounds wildly speculative and very much influenced by the specific metro. Most of the time in busy metros where those types of pedestrian and cyclist fatalities occur, traffic determines which route people take, not speed limit. One thing we all seem to agree on is that most freeway speed limits are too low.
- WalterBright 5y ago> That sounds wildly speculative Not at all. This was discovered when the speed limits were finally raised from 55. All the predictions were for a big rise in fatalities. Fatalities declined. Looking at traffic data explained it, with the drop in city street driving transferred to the freeways.
- listenallyall 5y ago> city streets, at lower speeds, has higher accident and fatality rates > people would eschew the city streets for the freeways. This is also the argument against HOV lanes or paid left lanes. Adding more congestion to highways (by restricting lanes) pushes more people towards surface streets, which, as you state, are less safe. Highways have lots of non-fatal accidents, while surface streets with lights and 4-ways tend to cause t-bones, head-ons, and have pedestrians and bikers around.
- 2muchcoffeeman 5y agoOnly because most people aren't doing it. Imagine if everyone was performing unneeded maneuvers all the time. Best case, they cause a traffic jam. Worst case they cause an accident.
- sarchertech 5y agoYou’ve never seen someone weaving in and out of traffic, cutting across 3 lanes at a time, and nearly clipping cars each time the change lanes? Or you’ve never seen someone driving 30 miles an hour faster than the people in the lane next to them? It wasn’t every day or every week, but I’ve seen it many times commuting into Atlanta over the years. But sure if you removed speed limits most people would continue driving at a safe speed. The problem is small minority who choose to go 30 over. You can still make that illegal and prosecute them under reckless driving laws. But then you’re just adding even more subjectivity to traffic enforcement. If you’re on a road without much traffic, what feels safe is subjective. It depends on what you’re used to and the car you’re driving.
- WalterBright 5y ago> You’ve never seen someone weaving in and out of traffic, cutting across 3 lanes at a time, and nearly clipping cars each time the change lanes? I have, and those driver(s) were clearly impaired - drunk or high. I did not propose removal of reckless or impaired driving laws. There are also laws against creating a hazard while driving, which would apply to driving 30mph faster than the adjacent traffic.
- sarchertech 5y agoWhat makes you so sure they were drunk or high? I’ve most often seen it during morning commutes, and the speed at which they were successfully pulling off multiple lane changes with very narrow margins leads me to believe they weren’t impaired. You could remove every driving law and just replace it with a single sentence—use common sense and don’t endanger other people by being reckless. But eventually after the 400th time someone does it, it starts to makes sense to add an optimization to the system that says “on this stretch of road driving faster than 100 mph is automatically reckless.”
- WalterBright 5y ago> What makes you so sure they were drunk or high? Inability to keep the car straight on a 4 lane freeway when there's no traffic means drunk or high. High speed recklessness to me is overdriving your ability to see ahead and react. This varies considerably even on the same stretch of road due to lighting, weather, traffic, etc. 60mph can be way too slow on a fine sunny day with no traffic, and insanely reckless on an icy day in high winds.
- greenburger 5y agoPerhaps where you drive is safer than where I do. I see dangerous driving multiple times a year and see recent accidents weekly (cars and cops on the side of the road). According to the NTSB: > "On the highways 100 people (are killed) a day," he said. "Every two days we are killing the equivalent of a Boeing 737 crashing. [0] Obviously, not all directly a result of “insanely dangerous” driving (including the primary topic of that article). But, my definition would include driving that results in fatal accidents. [0] https://lite.cnn.com/en/article/h_28168226adfec28da29cec92e72b990c https://lite.cnn.com/en/article/h_28168226adfec28da29cec92e7...
- oh_sigh 5y agoI would say it is insanely dangerous to put an unlicensed 13 year old behind the wheel of a 6000 lbs truck. Maybe the tire would have blown regardless of who was driving, but I have to suspect a 30+ year old construction worker would have better knowledge on how to safely bring a vehicle to a stop compared to a 13 year old kid.
- lmm 5y agoDrivers are one of the top killers of young people and a very significant cause of lost years of life, and speed is a factor in IIRC 73% of collisions. People do not generally drive at a safe speed in the US, rather they drive at a speed that seems safe because they've done it a bunch of times - the same kind of normalization of deviance as launching your space shuttle because it never burned through both O-rings the last 20 times.
- WalterBright 5y agoBut would that change if the speed limits were removed? I doubt it.
- lmm 5y agoMaybe speed limits aren't achieving much at the moment, but it must be possible to start enforcing them and gradually change that culture - after all, drunk driving used to be just as routine as speeding is now.
- dabbledash 5y agoWhat does “speed was a factor in 73% of collisions” mean?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- lmm 5y agoMost collisions are caused by a confluence of multiple factors, and reducing them to a single "cause" is misleading.
- dabbledash 5y agoThat doesn’t answer my question. To be more direct, I’m suspicious that this is just a misleading / question begging way of saying “in 73% of accidents, someone was speeding.” Which doesn’t really tell me anything unless I have already accepted the premise that speeding is usually a problem.
- raz32dust 5y agoThis is purely anecdotal and goes against all data. A simple search for "Are speed limits effective" will show you tons of past experiments. Safe speed limits, when enforced, are highly effective in reducing accidents and fatalities.
- WalterBright 5y agoWhat experiments removed the speed limits? Anyhow, there were experiments in Europe where all street signs were removed from small towns. Traffic accidents and deaths declined, contrary to all expectation.
- pmyteh 5y ago...because drivers slowed down, no longer being confident that they had effective priority and could drive at or above the posted limit as long as they stayed within the lines.
- WalterBright 5y agoThey removed the lines and the posted signs, too.
- pmyteh 5y agoIndeed. It's a fascinating, if counterintuitive, model. Remove all the usual signals that make drivers confident in what's going on, and so we have to think (and look) much harder and drive much slower. It has the consequence of giving de facto priority to pedestrians, too.
- porty 5y agoI find that enforced speeding fines (which doesn't seem to happen in the US) causes drivers to drive at different speeds, whether an individual at that speed is safe or not. Inconsistent driving speeds is a lot more difficult to drive in. If I had a vote (which I don't) I'd say increase all the limits by 10 mph (to reflect what people are doing now) but then also fine people that are speeding (like +2mph).