4 ms·
It should be much more cost-effective to float wind turbines to pump surface water to benthic depths. Then, the whole ocean is your CO2 collection surface. You
by ncmncm 5y ago
It should be much more cost-effective to float wind turbines to pump surface water to benthic depths. Then, the whole ocean is your CO2 collection surface. You might also pump water from (lesser) depths to the surface to distribute over coral reefs to relieve both heat and pH. (Picture a line of these some miles seaward, all up and down the Great Barrier Reef.)
The wind turbine nacelle could be substantially cheaper than in the typical electrical generating turbine, instead coupling mechanically or hydraulically to the water pump.
Some people worry that this would saturate the deep ocean with CO2. A bit of calculation shows this is an idle concern: the shallow ocean is already being saturated with CO2, with immediately dire consequences, and there is overwhelmingly more deep ocean water than surface water. So long as atmospheric CO2 falls off over the coming century, there would no long-term problem.
Geoengineering that tackles the root problem, CO2, is fundamentally different from schemes that only (e.g.) try to block insolation. Other engineering is going on to tackle upstream CO2 emission, but we have a huge stock of CO2 already built up in the atmosphere that will need to be drawn down.
- secondbreakfast 5y agoYou should build this! This is one of those "all of the above" moments.
- ncmncm 5y agoIt could be profitable if you sold carbon credits. The pH and water volume may be measured accurately on the way through, precisely identifying exactly how much CO2 is being sequestered. I don't know how the carbon credit economy works. I would welcome enlightenment.
- demircancelebi 5y agoAs I know there are some standards like https://www.goldstandard.org/ https://www.goldstandard.org/ and https://verra.org/ https://verra.org/ . They audit the projects that claim to remove CO2 from the atmosphere worldwide and issue CO2 credits. These credits then can be sold to companies that want to offset their emissions. Usually OTC deals, sometimes involving brokers as well. There's also https://www.cblmarkets.net/ https://www.cblmarkets.net/ , which is one of the big marketplaces where such deals are happening. I've heard deals with prices in the range of $0.5 to $5 per tonne CO2 equivalent. There's also a decentralized protocol that aims to move these credits onchain (https://toucan.earth/ https://toucan.earth/), their BCT (Base Carbon Tonne) token price is currently around $3.1. As stated in the post, last year ~$1B worth of credits are sold. One McKinsey report expects it to be around $50B at 2030. There are much more details of course, but these are the basics as I know.
- markcyffka 5y agoToday we see a moment when popular interest, need, capital, and talent are converging on a willingness to to try new things with a path to success. Who knows how long the window will last. We must try to advance any path that has some chance of succeeding and has a technically/commercially viable path forward.
- alexose 5y agoThis is really well said. As a person who lived through the first dot-com boom, this feels a lot like the 90's. There are way more ideas than there are viable paths forward. But among these ideas, there's at least a handful of future giants.
- pvarangot 5y agoI think the problem with that approach is that it would be harder to establish a regulatory framework were you can get "I sequestered CO2 credits" if your pumps are out in the ocean and pumping the CO2 into deeper waters. The capturing facilities inland are easier to audit and regulate. So yeah maybe it's better for the planet but since it's harder to regulate it would be tricky to get funding to build that if the potential profit comes from the government intervening to set a price for the CO2 removal you are doing.
- ncmncm 5y agoPumped water volume and pH are easy to measure, precisely identifying how much CO2 is being sequestered. These could be reported continuously via satellite link. It doesn't cost any less to keep a wind turbine and pump still than to leave it running, so there will be no incentive to cheat.
- ElevenLathe 5y agoI don't know anything specifically about wind turbine maintenance, but if its anything like everything else I know about, it probably does cost more to have 99% uptime than it does to have 80% uptime.
- ncmncm 5y agoConceded. But with automated reporting from metering equipment, it would be easy to tell when it stopped working, and if that meant the money stopped, you would be motivated to get out there and get it going again. We will need thousands of these things, all over the world. Maybe even millions.
- pvarangot 5y agoI was not thinking it was a technological challenge, I was more concerned about how useless governments in general are at regulating stuff that happens in the sea. There's no civil arm of the government that runs around in boats inspecting and certifying stuff.
- gridspy 5y agoSounds like it would also directly cool surface water, by replacing it with very cold deep water. That cooling would directly reduce current average earth temperatures, in addition to the CO2 impact on long term heating / cooling.
- Kirinius 5y agoNot sure in which measure this "cooling" (of oceans only) would have any impact on other parameters of global climate, but that's a project I'd be eager to work on anyways.
- ncmncm 5y agoThe ocean surface, when colder, absorbs heat from the atmosphere. But the effect of removing CO2 is much more important because CO2 blocks heat that comes in every day from space from escaping back to space. And, acidifies the ocean top, damaging the food chain at its roots.
- mNovak 5y agoNot to derail the OP discussion; but, how does one go about pumping water to great depths? That sounds like it would require immense energy to do on any large scale. Also thinking of the maintenance on the presumably narrow vertical pipe going miles(?) below the ocean.
- ncmncm 5y agoIt does take energy to pump water. How much is easy to calculate. But if the energy is provided by capturing wind, the cost is just the fixed capital expenditure to buy the wind turbine and pump, plus (as always) maintenance on the turbine, pump, and plumbing. Maintaining a pipe, even one a half-mile long, is pretty cheap. (It has floats along its length, so it doesn't need to be especially strong.) Probably the biggest maintenance chore is keeping the intake from being fouled with barnacles, something most easily handled by replacing linings periodically.
- tkanarsky 5y agoHmm, off the top of my head I think that it takes as much energy to pump water down a 1-foot tube as it would for a 1000-foot tube. It's like rotating a long loop of chain on a pulley, but in three dimensions. One liter of water goes down the tube, one liter of water comes up around the tube. Both sides weigh equal amounts so there's no net force. Of course, overcoming inertia to get the water moving and keeping it moving despite friction might be significant. Ironically, a consequence of the oil industry is that we have powerful pumps that are proven to be economical in moving large amounts of liquids long distances through pipes :)
- peter422 5y agoThere is significant friction between the water and the tube that needs to be accounted for. The longer the tube, the more friction there is.
- ncmncm 5y agoBut the bigger its cross section, and the slower the water inside moves, the less friction there is. A fabric tube 10 or 20 feet across would work as well as a pipe. It could stick up a few feet above the surface, and the pump just lift water over the edge into it.
- joefigura 5y agoThis doesn't remove CO2 from the ocean, right? It instead mixes the ocean better to increase the total CO2 absorbed in the ocean, reducing atmospheric CO2? It sounds like a cool idea but is not really related to what AirMyne is trying to do! Lots of ideas are promising and people need to be working on all of them
- ncmncm 5y agoAirMyne is trying to remove CO2 from the atmosphere and sequester it attached to rocks underground. Pumping surface water down sequesters surface water down deep that recently collected CO2 from the atmosphere, and exposes incrementally less-saturated surface water to collect more. The important difference is not how the CO2 is collected, or where it ends up. Ultimately, what matters is how much mass of CO2 is collected per unit cost, and how much CO2 is collected in total. I.e., how profitable is it, and how much difference does it really make? We need methods that can move CO2 out of the atmosphere by, ultimately, billions of tons per week.
- shafyy 5y agoI'm not a marine or ocean expert, but won't pumping large amounts of surface water to benthic depths have a huge impact on the marine life, currents and so on?
- ncmncm 5y agoWe are already making a huge impact on marine life, today, with increasingly disastrous consequences. This reduces that impact.
- tinco 5y agoWhere did you learn about this idea? I've been trying to get up to speed on climate change solutions and I thought I heard just about everything but this is the first I've heard this solution and it sounds like it might make total sense. Are there companies developing these pump mills?
- tinco 5y agoAlso, wouldn't it be even nicer to pump up the cold water? That way you decrease the acidity of the surface water more strongly, increasing the acidic uptake of the surface water, and you also cool it down more. If we did that for example in the East Australian Current north of Vanuatu, we might help out the Great Barrier Reef a little, moderating both the temperature and the acidity. It's like 3 birds with one stone. I guess pumping up has the additional complexity of having the intake all the way down at 2KM, which is also where you'd need to do the maintenance. But maybe you could float up the entire pipe for maintenance. Seems a similar idea has been proposed, but from a depth of a mere 40m: https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/apr/07/plan-cold-water-barrier-reef-stop-bleaching https://www.theguardian.com/environment/2017/apr/07/plan-col....
- ncmncm 5y agoYes, there is lots of room for development, and connected ideas. Where waves are available, the wind turbine might not be needed. Waves tend to happen mostly where water is shallow. Anyway, idea is that you have a big, floating, anchored fabric tube with rim held above mean surface level, that waves slop into. Once water is in, the only exit is way down deep. So more water slops in all the time, and moves down under the weight of what comes in after it. Then, you need no wind turbine, no pumps, no moving parts at all; just anchors, floats, a surface frame, and a few thousand square yards of very tough fabric. The tube doesn't need to go straight down. It could collect water in (relative) shallows and exhaust it some distance off, at cost of just more fabric.
- ncmncm 5y agoA proposal showed up here on HN, maybe a month ago. I will try to find it. It seems like a good place to invest.
- specialist 5y agoChurning ocean water is a terrific idea. Especially the added benefit protecting habitats. Thanks for sharing. -- I also have no clue about the economics of carbon capture. Maybe ask David Roberts? He has always answered my emails. (Note he's currently on vacation.) Roberts is my current primary source for climate and energy policy news. He definitely talks to all the right people, eg Saul Griffins. Here's a sample of his articles which may be relevant to your question: These uses of CO2 could cut emissions — and make trillions of dollars [2019] https://www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/2019/11/13/20839531/climate-change-industry-co2-carbon-capture-utilization-storage-ccu https://www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/2019/11/13/208395... A simpler, more useful way to tax carbon [2020] https://www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/2020/8/17/21370732/carbon-tax-simple-useful-nt2nz https://www.vox.com/energy-and-environment/2020/8/17/2137073... Volts podcast: Sen. Tina Smith on the promise of a Clean Electricity Payment Program [2021] https://www.volts.wtf/p/volts-podcast-sen-tina-smith-on-the https://www.volts.wtf/p/volts-podcast-sen-tina-smith-on-the Volts podcast: Rebecca Dell on decarbonizing heavy industry [2022] https://www.volts.wtf/p/volts-podcast-rebecca-dell-on-decarbonizing https://www.volts.wtf/p/volts-podcast-rebecca-dell-on-decarb...