5 ms·
Resale of these is going to be crazy. Pick one up on the flipside for $100 after xmas. Bluetooth? No HDMI? No Camera? No Microphone? No micro/SD slot
by ck2 15y ago
Resale of these is going to be crazy. Pick one up on the flipside for $100 after xmas.
Bluetooth? No
HDMI? No
Camera? No
Microphone? No
micro/SD slot? No
GPS? No
3G? No
Android Market? No (only Amazon Market)
- TylerE 15y agoTo repeat history: No wireless. Less space than a nomad. Lame.
- ellyagg 15y agoIt's good for CmdrTacoMalda that he's too busy trying to get his site back up after its current HNing. Otherwise, he'd probably have time to read and be annoyed again by this comment. ;)
- mmatants 15y agoI have seen this feature "chart" pasted into HN posts before. Didn't folks slam the original iPhone the same way? Not to say that the Fire is a guaranteed hit, but I think that as a consumption device aimed at consumers it needs very little of those features.
- burgerbrain 15y agoThe iphone and the ipod before it..
- troymc 15y agoAmazon probably did market research to determine what people would really want. When I read your list of things the Fire doesn't have, I realized I wouldn't miss any of them.
- Leynos 15y agoIf it's missing an SD card slot, I'd miss that. 8GB isn't that much space when you're talking video. That said, $200 is getting dangerously near the comfort zone for a device purely bought with the intention of using it around the house (where WiFi negates the need for large onboard storage).
- calloc 15y agoI thought you didn't need to keep all your videos on your device. You could archive and re-download whenever you wanted much like the Kindle app on iOS?
- khafra 15y agoFree cloud helps (although I think that only applies to stuff you've gotten through Amazon), but even if just for the airplane use case, it'd be nice to have the option to carry a bandolier of sd cards.
- nhangen 15y agoYou forgot to mention that the price is $200 under what most tablets cost. This is just the first iteration, but I fully expect the Amazon market to become relevant as a result of this device's popularity.
- mrchess 15y agoConsumers are starting to lose themselves in unecessary features. Do you really need any of this to use the Kindle Fire for what it was meant for -- a cheap portable book/game/movie viewer? To each his own, but I bought the new Kindle for this reason. I own a Kindle Keyboard, but it was just too much -- I just wanted a barebones reader. Even the touch, IMO, is overkill -- who really needs to "touch" what is supposed to be a book? So I picked up the $79 Kindle and was very happy. It's really thin, great aesthetics, and has all the barebone features I need to do one job really well.
- notatoad 15y agoif people are buying it as a cheap portable book/game/movie player, then yeah those features are unnecessary. but from everything i've heard, the primary thing driving returns on android tablets so far isn't that people dislike it, it's that people expect more than it is. some overeager salesperson or fanboy tells people that an android tablet can replace your computer, people get annoyed that it's just a tablet. if amazon is successfully managing expectations for this product, it has plenty of features. if the fanboys get out of control and oversell it, then it is sorely lacking.
- wanorris 15y agoOne of the reasons people "expect more than it is" is that it's hard for an average consumer to get an Android tablet to do anything out of the box. A Kindle Fire, by contrast, puts media front and center right away, and will surely make the store as easily accessible as it is on the e-ink Kindles. It's a Kindle, so right off the bat, you can read books. You get a free trial of Prime, so right off the bat, you can watch video. Presumably they will make it easy to understand the process for getting your music into the Amazon cloud (or copied on to the device), and I'm sure it won't be too hard to go get hooked up with a copy of Angry Birds, or whatever other games and starter apps they're pushing. And as long as Amazon has a credit card on file for you (pretty likely if you're buying an Amazon tablet), purchasing whatever it is you want will be ridiculously simple, just like on the Kindle. It should be a fairly batteries-included experience for the vast majority of users right out of the box.
- pavel_lishin 15y ago90% of my use case for one of these would be on a train or a bus. No reception for 3G or GPS, no use for a camera/microphone/HDMI/card slots. Blue tooth might be handy if I had blue tooth headphones, which I don't.
- SandB0x 15y agoDoes it have a good browser? Can it access Gmail, YouTube and Facebook? In that case 90% of people will be happy with it. I know I would be, if I could buy it in the UK.
- chaz 15y agoRemember all of the stuff that the iPhone lacked when it launched? No 3G. No copy/paste. No third party apps. No Flash. No carrier choice. No removable battery. No OTA syncing. No Exchange. 2 MP camera. No front camera. Watered down Bluetooth. Amazon isn't Apple (yet?), but the focus on experience and not features is what's going to make or break Kindle in the long run.
- ConstantineXVI 15y agoBonus: the original iPhone was $600 (later $400) /on contract/, and it still sold like hotcakes. This is a $200 tablet with no carrier allegiance required.
- michaelbuckbee 15y agoI think your last point is interesting as I view that as a clear positive from a user experience point of view.
- kenjackson 15y agoYou forgot 4G LTE. The Xoom has all of those features and because of it, it is flying off the shelves -- err, no, wait a second. Nilay Patal had a great quote about the Fire v iPad. He said the Fire actually competes with the iPad not because it does more, but because it does less.
- alexwolfe 15y agoSelling 100,000 in a day: Yes Its not a feature war :) I couldn't give a flip about everything you just mentioned. Here's the real test: Great product: yes That is all that matters.
- srdev 15y agoBluetooth? -- Don't need it. Only accessory I would use is bluetooth headphones, and wired is good enough. HDMI? -- Don't need it, why would I hook my tablet to my TV? Camera? -- Don't need it, I have a camera and a cell phone. Microphone? -- Why would I need a microphone on a tablet? micro/SD slot? -- Don't need it, my content is stored on Amazon's servers. It has enough physical space for content when I'm on the go. GPS? -- Don't need it, I'm not using this for maps on the go. That's what my cell phone is for. 3G? -- One valid point. Android Market? -- The most valid point, but not a deal-breaker. Lists like these are almost always ignorant of typical use cases. That's partly why Apple does so well -- they engineer for the typical use, even if it excludes power users.