4 ms·
Hydrogen has 3x the mass-energy density of kerosene, what is called "aviation fuel". However, LH2 takes up too much room to fit in the wings, so the LH2 tanks
by ncmncm 5y ago
Hydrogen has 3x the mass-energy density of kerosene, what is called "aviation fuel".
However, LH2 takes up too much room to fit in the wings, so the LH2 tanks need to be somewhere else, either inboard or in nacelles. And you have to liquify it, which takes up some more energy. But the weight advantage will prove overwhelming, particularly as raw electricity costs continue on down.
The reason the weight advantage is so overwhelming is that each kg of fuel not carried is another kg of cargo you can carry, instead, and collect revenue for. For example, an Airbus A320 carries typically, say, 25t of fuel and 50t of cargo. Replacing that with 8t of fuel and 67t of cargo yields a 34% revenue increase. If kerosene-fueled planes are getting a 20% gross profit margin, you can absolutely undercut them anywhere you fly. So, you pick up all of the most profitable traffic, and they are left to fly the routes you don't want.
That presumes the per-joule cost of LH2 is the same as for Jet-A fuel. But as the LH2 is synthesized on-site, vs. Jet-A mined, refined, transported, and maybe carbon-taxed, a joule of LH2 could be substantially cheaper. With time, kerosene will come to be synthesized, but it needs carbon captured from somewhere, either from the air or from somebody's exhaust, and the oxygen stripped off, and hydrogen stuck on its place, and chains built up, so will cost more.
- danans 5y ago> Hydrogen has 3x the energy density of kerosene, what is called "aviation fuel". You are confusing "specific energy" (energy/mass) with "energy density" (energy/volume). Hydrogen has 3x the specific energy of kerosene, but 1/4 the energy density at the same pressure.
- ncmncm 5y agoFor aviation, specific energy, or mass-energy density, wins. Lofted volume is cheap, lofted weight is dear.
- danans 5y agoYou still need to compress and contain hydrogen to get an amount of energy practicable for flight. Hydrogen, even when compressed to 700 bar only provides 1.4kWh/L [1]. Kerosene provides 10kWh/L. A 747 uses 36k liters (36 cubic meters) kerosene for a 10 hour flight, or 360MWh. [2] With 700bar H2, that amount of energy requires 260k liters (260 cubic meters), not counting the thicker storage vessel needed. 260 cubic meters seems tractable (assuming you can safely loft 700 bar hydrogen), although still takes an order of magnitude more space than kerosene. Since we know how to safely loft syn fuels, and we have a fleet of aircraft that can use them, it might make more sense to go that route. It would also allow blending into the existing jet fuel supply infrastructure along with kerosene and biofuels. 1. https://www.energy.gov/eere/fuelcells/physical-hydrogen-storage https://www.energy.gov/eere/fuelcells/physical-hydrogen-stor... 2. https://science.howstuffworks.com/transport/flight/modern/question192.htm https://science.howstuffworks.com/transport/flight/modern/qu...
- ncmncm 5y agoNobody would even consider lofting compressed hydrogen, under any circumstances. It is actively misleading, even dishonest, to bring it up. The topic here is LH2, liquified hydrogen.
- danans 5y agoLH2 energy density is still only 2.3kWh/L, 1/4 of kerosene or synfuel. It also needs to be kept at -253C. > Nobody would even consider lofting compressed hydrogen The HY4 prototype aircraft uses hydrogen compressed to 350 bar: https://www.compositesworld.com/amp/news/hydrogen-fuel-cell-powered-hy4-aircraft-takes-flight https://www.compositesworld.com/amp/news/hydrogen-fuel-cell-...
- ncmncm 5y agoThe heading of the linked article reads "MAHEPA consortium demonstrates feasibility and advances toward liquid hydrogen tanks" Again, volumetric density is of little consequence for aviation. See above. You are visibly reaching. Why reach?
- danans 5y agoI'm "provoking" the question of synthetic aviation fuel versus hydrogen, which is hardly settled, and hardly provocative.
- ncmncm 5y agoYou are repeatedly throwing up known irrelevancies. Hydrogen, by the way, is also synthetic, and also fuel, and also usable for aviation. Thus, "synthetic LH2 aviation fuel". So, no, you are apparently trying, instead, to promote synthetic or mined kerosene, and doing it by trying to distract attention from its most appealing alternative. Ineptly. We know that mined kerosene will become increasingly expensive, relative to synthesized hydrogen, as electric power cost declines. Synthetic kerosene might become cheaper than mined, or anyway than mined-plus-carbon-taxes. It will certainly never be cheaper than hydrogen, which is an essential ingredient. Will synthetic kerosene be able to compete with the radically better value proposition of LH2 fuel? Only insofar as synthetic kerosene helps to preserve the capital value of existing airframes. But airframes have to be replaced anyway as they age out.
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slush_hydrogen https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slush_hydrogen
- ncmncm 5y agoLooks like you need to maintain minus 13/14 of an atmosphere while producing it. Probably the frozen stuff is stable at atmospheric pressure, once formed.