3 ms·
That's not the question. The point is whether you are entitled to feel an author is cheating you by not writing a new novel in a series you like. My contention
by tsimionescu 5y ago
That's not the question. The point is whether you are entitled to feel an author is cheating you by not writing a new novel in a series you like.
My contention is that George RR Martin is cheating his ASOIAF readers by spending time on other works instead of writing the next ASOIAF novel.
By contrast, I don't think Agatha Christie would have been cheating her Poirot fans in any way by writing Miss Marple novels instead of Poirot ones.
The reason I draw this difference is that you can enjoy (or hate) any particular Poirot book individually. By contrast, you can't really like A Dance With Dragons without knowing if what happens next to some of those characters actually resolves the tension and mystery in a satisfying way (or doesn't resolve it, but in a satisfying meaningful way, like a good open ending).