3 ms·
”If the estimate of U.S. intelligence is correct, the Russian military has lost more troops in Iraq than it has lost in Afghanistan in 20 years,” the report sai
by refurb 5y ago
”If the estimate of U.S. intelligence is correct, the Russian military has lost more troops in Iraq than it has lost in Afghanistan in 20 years,” the report said.”
Iraq? That’s some mighty fine proof reading.
And is this the same US intelligence that said Iraq has WMDs?
- ceejayoz 5y ago> And is this the same US intelligence that said Iraq has WMDs? To be fair, it's the same US intelligence that correctly predicted pretty much every move Putin made leading up to the invasion.
- 988747 5y agoAnd "Iraq has WMDs" was a deliberate lie, not a mistake. I assume they have no reason to lie about number of Russian casualties.
- bayesian_horse 5y agoThe CIA didn't lie. And the Bush government's lie wasn't that they believed Iraq to have WMDs, the lie was in the exaggeration of their evidence. Ironically, almost everyone in the region had WMDs, including the Isrealis. Even Saddam Hussein must have had some at some point, particularly when he used them against the Kurds. So it's not so easy and clear-cut.
- refurb 5y agoA deliberate lie sounds worse than a mistake.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoI belive the US intellegence also was correct about the WMDs but the politicians didn't like their answer and basically got them to come up with an answer they liked instead so they could go ahead with a planned invasion they'd been working on for decades. Ironically seems like Russia might have just done the same thing. edit this link factchecks intelligence Vs politicians: https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/03/22/iraq-war-wmds-an-intelligence-failure-or-white-house-spin/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/2019/03/22/iraq-war-... And has this particularly damning factoid: > One problem is that few members of Congress actually read the classified 2002 NIE. Instead, they relied on the sanitized version distributed to the public, which was scrubbed of dissenting opinions. (It was later learned that the public white paper had been drafted long before the NIE had been requested by Congress, even though the white paper was publicly presented as a distillation of the NIE. So that should count as another manipulation of public opinion.)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- jmull 5y agoHere's the original sentence (NYT article) this was butchered from: > The conservative side of the estimate, at more than 7,000 Russian troop deaths, is greater than the number of American troops killed over 20 years in Iraq and Afghanistan combined. They managed to change which military, the current war and the comparison wars in one bad edit.
- glogla 5y ago> And is this the same US intelligence that said Iraq has WMDs? I heard an interesting explanation for that - intelligence agencies don't deal well with adversaries that lie to themselves. Allegedly they had captured communication of Saddam bragging to his inner circle that his WMDs are ready and will be used soon ... but he didn't actually have any. Oops. Same with overestimating Russian ability to wage war - when you capture communication that says "we have 30 planes ready" it is hard to know that 10 of those are fictional and 10 are broken because people routinely lie to their bosses. But it might be bunch of excuses, who knows.
- albertopv 5y agoAfter almost 20 years we can assume it's not the same intelligence.