3 ms·
>By comparison, fans of Agatha Christie's work would not have any entitlement to complain if she stopped after three novels Of course they would.
by thfuran 5y ago
>By comparison, fans of Agatha Christie's work would not have any entitlement to complain if she stopped after three novels
Of course they would.
- tsimionescu 5y agoWhy? Do you feel that The Murder of Roger Ackroyd is not telling a complete story unless you also read Murder on the Orient Express? Note that I'm not saying some fans wouldn't have been pressuring her into writing more if she had stopped. I'm saying those fans, unlike the ASOIAF fandom, wouldn't have a leg to stand on.
- lupire 5y ago"complete story" doesn't exist. Every story has details not followed up on. Just like real life. LOST had an ending but it was terrible because the story kept piling on more bullshit. GOT TV had an ending and it was terrible. ASOIAF is a short chronicle (yet still full of many great characterizations, episodes, and plot lines) of characters coming and going through the world. Some plot lines start in the middle, some end in the middle, because neither us nor GRRM are immortal beings.
- thfuran 5y ago>Do you feel that The Murder of Roger Ackroyd is not telling a complete story unless you also read Murder on the Orient Express? That's completely irrelevant. Everyone is entitled to feel however they feel and think whatever they think and should not be precluded from voicing their opinions. Why should your opinion of the relative completeness of one story versus another determine whether someone else is permitted to express disappointment with a story?
- tsimionescu 5y agoThat's not the question. The point is whether you are entitled to feel an author is cheating you by not writing a new novel in a series you like. My contention is that George RR Martin is cheating his ASOIAF readers by spending time on other works instead of writing the next ASOIAF novel. By contrast, I don't think Agatha Christie would have been cheating her Poirot fans in any way by writing Miss Marple novels instead of Poirot ones. The reason I draw this difference is that you can enjoy (or hate) any particular Poirot book individually. By contrast, you can't really like A Dance With Dragons without knowing if what happens next to some of those characters actually resolves the tension and mystery in a satisfying way (or doesn't resolve it, but in a satisfying meaningful way, like a good open ending).