4 ms·
I don't know The Kingiller Chronicles so I'm not going to comment on that, but I don't think you can call A Song of Ice and Fire a masterpiece until you see it'
by tsimionescu 5y ago
I don't know The Kingiller Chronicles so I'm not going to comment on that, but I don't think you can call A Song of Ice and Fire a masterpiece until you see it's ending. A lot of the quality is in the intricate plots it implies, but it has yet to resolve the vast majority of them, and if it falls flat, a lot of the majesty of what was started will turn put to have been smoke and mirrors.
This is what the Game of Thrones TV show proved: overall the show should not be considered a masterpiece, even though the early seasons seemed good at the time, since the stories they were telling mostly led nowhere. Sure, it had its excellent moments, but that's about it - overall, it was a show about the good guys winning easily, women being irrational and just kinda forgetting, armies fighting without consequences, and so on. The fact that the early seasons made you think it would be a different story was proven an illusion by the end.
- iamsaitam 5y agoThis is the issue in today's market driven society, there's a big crowd which seems very open to forgetting the pleasures brought up during the development process, when the end comes and is not to their liking. They would all be much more content if they weren't so keen in erasing their own memory.
- tsimionescu 5y agoThis is not a property of the market driven economy, it is a property of storytelling. For example, a story can have certain themes building up and exploring what you think are interesting directions, only for the ending to show a terrible conclusion to that theme. To give an extreme hypothetical example, lots of fantasy stories explore issues of race, and one could imagine a series that builds up a race conflict with complex characters on both sides, with only thinly veiled references to the real wod. If then the book were to end by showing that characters of a dark-skinned race are simply too stupid and evil, with even the moat interesting of them falling prey to his race's tendency for being criminal, readers would justifiably be horrified by the ending, and feel that the apparently interesting direction they were being led on was a lie, retroactively regretting having been nodding along with the author.
- oneoff786 5y agoHuh. I only watched the show and I felt it was much more guys being idiots, and women tending to be wiser if gender lines must be drawn. I thought the show, despite very poor quality writing for the final seasons, managed its plot lines pretty well. It didn’t bring in all the threads but it finished most of the ones that started. But the tone of things changed quite a bit following the red wedding. The red wedding, and the execution of Ned, were two fairly surprising events. They greatly shifted the arc of the story, and added a lot of drama to the world. After this event I felt everyone started wearing their plot armor heavily. Main characters went off on their adventures and couldn’t plausibly die without making a good deal of the story otherwise pointless to have pre existed. I didn’t feel anyone’s death mattered after those two events, which frankly is also fine. That’s a cool, novel story structure in itself.
- tsimionescu 5y agoWell, of the main female characters, one ends up an isolationist, another is a psychotic assassin who fed a lord his own children, two literally go mad and kill thousands, and only one has any positive development, the most mannish of them. > It didn’t bring in all the threads but it finished most of the ones that started. It finished them in abrupt ways that made all of the build-up irrelevant, and proved all of the thematic elements simple misreadings. Particularly the White Walkers were turned from a world-ending problem that could only be confronted using humanity's entire attention, from which political squabbles were a silly distraction, into a simple horde of zombies that could easily be killed by stabbing their leader with a good weapon, and who couldn't even destroy half of a band of light cavalry facing them in an open field. Also, Daenerys's complex character build-up, with elements of genuine desire to create a new Era of prosperity, but self-righteous belief in her own right to be at the head of that new Era, was made irrelevant as she became a raving genocidal maniac when her father's bad blood got to her seeing the old seat of her family's power. This is all glossing over all of the nonsensical decisions made by characters, the unexamined hypocrisy (to name the most egregious one, Daenerys executing a trusted advisor trying to poison her is presented as abhorrent, while Jon hanging the conspirators who killed him is presented as righteous, even if one of them was a 10 year old child).
- 5y ago
- fao_ 5y agoThis is what the Game of Thrones TV show proved: overall the show should not be considered a masterpiece, even though the early seasons seemed good at the time, since the stories they were telling mostly led nowhere. Oh, for only you could provide that wonderful evidence of which you talk about -- that proof for the first half of this quote. If only you could enlighten us all, cast the drapes from our eyes, and elucidate what difference lies between the fact of merely hinting at plots, and having an ending written, versus having the plots written, but the ending languishing in dreams. Sure, it had its excellent moments, but that's about it - overall, it was a show about the good guys winning easily, women being irrational and just kinda forgetting, armies fighting without consequences, and so on. The fact that the early seasons made you think it would be a different story was proven an illusion by the end. Thus, I am to take it that you feel the end of a work invalidates the whole? If I may be so bold as to talk about my experience, I find myself most content to read the latter half of a work, and circle around to the start. While I find myself most humble in hopefully not alluding to presume the minds of others, I do not think that the majority of people who cast their eyes over The Lord Of The Rings do so merely because they wish to find out what happens at the end? Surely, if they do so they must be rather disappointed by all of the videos and movies put forth in the years hence, that describe to one's eyes and culture the most intricate details of the ending in exact terms. It seems rather well documented, indeed -- it has been subsumed into our very culture, that the short of stature hobbits win their restless battle, in the end. That "Good" wins, and "Bad" fails. Alas, what reason is there to read the book now? For you already know the ending, why should one know the journey? Why open a book for which you know in advance the ending? Oh, simply the writer's prose, I suppose. Perhaps even, the skill and wit and deft of description. Merely the entire story and content of those soft white pages, before the last handful. From your perspective, surely you deem such things to be inadequate? After all, since a story only holds merit, if the ending holds merit, how could such things matter! I'll assent, that to be let down by an ending that you feel is shoddy or hastily jotted down by a perhaps all-too-sleep-deprived author, feels like being besmirched by their very hand at a prim and proper dinner party. And I shall even assent that these are all personal feelings, forthwit! What a dull and dreary world you must live in, it makes one sad. I truly pity you, and hope you too one day come to know the pleasure of taking the journey of things, and not just the finality.
- seba_dos1 5y agoSo, what I take from your comment is that the author should simply declare the ending to be open and get a masterpiece status for free now instead of having to think hard about a satisfactory ending that could drag the whole story down!
- tsimionescu 5y agoWell, an open ending can itself be satisfying or not. The current state of ASOIAF would have about 30 open major plots, most without any discernible relevant theme at their current state, so I would say that no, it would end up in the "irrelevant story with some nice ideas along the way" state if the last two books were truly the end of the story. Note the RR Martin does actually have many sci-fi stories with interesting, frustrating but thematically clear, open endings.
- the_af 5y ago> it was a show about the good guys winning easily We must have watched a different show. It was a show about the good guys losing, people who were "right" being killed, people who were "wrong" mostly being in command until very late in the show, and potential heroes being offed in the first season. There was a whole bunch of memes about not getting too attached to a likable "good" character, since Martin was likely to kill him/her.
- tsimionescu 5y agoAnd yet, in the end, the good guys won, this is my point. The bad guys had a few temporary wins along the way, but they all lost in the end. Every last bad character died, almost all good characters survived and became the new lords and ladies of Westeros.
- the_af 5y agoSort of. The good guys won at the very end, and it wasn't easy. And lots of good characters were tortured and died along the way. It wasn't a clear cut "easy" win for the good guys. A major moral character dies in the first season!
- tsimionescu 5y agoThey won the "Battle for the Dawn" in a few hours only losing half their army or less and only two significant characters mid-way through the season. They then won the final battle with even fewer losses after a few hours of fighting, with no major characters dying, in what would have been a clean victory where they would have been hailed as saviors, had Daenerys not gone insane after the victory. Even she was then easily defeated, with little consequence for her killer or the former prime Minister who publically condemned her, despite the fact that the kingdom was under the control of her fanatically loyal general and his fanatically loyal troops. There were more characters committing what amounted to suicide in the final few season than those who were killed by the horrors of war or scheming enemies. I would call all of this quite easy. Sure, along the way in previous seasons, a lot were tortured and died, but many of them turned out not to matter too much at all in the overall plot (particularly, Rob Stark, and arguably, Jamie Lannister).
- Maursault 5y agoI think you're using the term, masterpiece, too loosely. Martin's works are novels filled with stories, but there are not many interpretations of what he is describing. There are not layers upon layers of meaning, but instead, it simply is what it is, and there is little to no argument about what his words mean. J.R.R. Tolkien is a favorite of mine, but I would not talk about his writing skill, and what is fascinating about Tolkien has nothing to do with is writing but the world he created. I think Martin has similarities in this regard. But The Lord of the Rings has many interpretations. A Song of Fire and Ice, not so much. The Renaissance frescoes by Michelangelo at the Sistine Chapel is a masterpiece, no one would rationally disagree. In comparison, A Song of Fire and Ice is merely pulp, i.e. popular writing that is generally regarded by academic experts of writing as poor quality. Tolkien influenced academics, and you can study Tolkien in certain lectures. Even Rowling is studied. I seriously doubt any university level professor would pull out A Song of Fire and Ice, or any of Martin's work, and develop a seminar around it, or spend a semester studying it to reveal the levels of complexity and novel style of prose, because it simply isn't there. Martin is very much a two dimensional thinker that writes in one linear dimension, his words have one single meaning, and scratching past the shallow surface of Martin's words doesn't reveal anything below it beyond the story it is telling. I think you should read more Melville, Hemingway, Miller, Dostoyevski, Tolstoy, Twain, Steinbeck, Salinger, Bradbury and Vonnegut, and many many others, before ever claiming anything by Martin is a "masterpiece." Just try to get out more.
- tsimionescu 5y agoThank you for assuming my reading level. If you must know, I greatly enjoy (and have extensively read) people like Rushdie, Marquez, Kawabata, Hesse, Wolf and many others who indeed have a very specific and masterful writing style. I do agree that Martin doesn't have a way with words the way the greatest writers do - his writing is quite flat in terms of style. I disagree (tentatively) that ASOIAF is mere pulp - I think it makes some interesting social commentary, particularly on the effects of war and how it leaves everyone, winner or loser, worse off than they were (in his personal life, he was a conscientious objector and is a lifetime pacifist, so I do believe that these themes are likely to be intentional). He also seems to be making a point about how political concerns rightly or wrongly stop the world from acting against ever more clear and imminent threats, with the Long Night probably being an allegory for Global Warming. But, the jury is still out until he actually finishes his work. It may turn out that I'm reading entirely too much into this, and that the ending will be similar to the show, where righteous war wins the day (as long as you don't commit atrocities) and the long night is not a crucial problem to be fixed, but a mere zombie distraction from the important political topics of the day. If we ever got an ending like this (I do not believe we will ever get an ending of any kind), I would then agree with you that this is a work of pulp fantasy with little literary merit. But if the ending makes good on these themes, it may turn out to be a true masterpiece, even if the writing style is quite flat. There are, after all, writers like Balzac, who is still taught and studied and read, even if his writing style (at least in the translations I've read) is just as flat.