3 ms·
There seems to be a huge difference in the quantity of asteroids below 1 AU, and those above. Almost as if something changes at exactly 1 AU. Even though Earth
by dotancohen 5y ago
There seems to be a huge difference in the quantity of asteroids below 1 AU, and those above. Almost as if something changes at exactly 1 AU.
Even though Earth is special for harbouring life, is the location of Earth really that significant from the perspective of how many objects could have smaller orbits? The "goldilocks zone" shouldn't determine the density of objects in any particular orbit.
Or is the issue that it is easier to detect asteroids further away than it is to detect asteroids closer to the sun?
- jcims 5y agoNote the scale, it appears to be logarithmic, so the effect is a bit exaggerated. The band of asteroids between Mars and Jupiter probably would have coalesced into a planet but Jupiter kept perturbing their orbits enough to prevent that from happening. Great image!
- tomr_stargazer 5y agoThere are a few observational biases at play here: * objects closer to the Sun are intrinsically brighter (as they are simply reflecting sunlight; their intrinsic brightness follows an inverse-square law[0]) * objects closer to the Earth are easier to see (for a similar reason: the amount of light that reaches us depends on those objects' distance from our telescopes; the combined effects of the above two points means that the observed brightness of asteroids approximately follows an inverse-fourth-power law far from the Earth) * objects interior to the Earth's orbit are hard to see because the Sun is in the way (it's usually daytime when these objects are "up"). So, even if there was a uniform distribution of asteroids as a function of orbital separation from the Sun, an observed overdensity of objects should be apparent just outside the Earth's orbit. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverse-square_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inverse-square_law See also sibling comment from jcims noting the logarithmic scaling, which would compress large separations and expand small separations.
- Symmetry 5y agoThose biases exist but don't explain why we see more asteroids between Jupiter and Mars than between Mars and Earth. There really is a much larger concentration of asteroids in the asteroid belt.
- dotancohen 5y agoYes, I'm not referring to the asteroid belt but to the phenomenon that below 1 AU there is a sharp drop in the quantity of asteroids shown in that map.