3 ms·
> But I'll freely admit that having spent more than a decade as a network engineer my expectations may be weird. I think you're correct in that regard. I'm an
by bayindirh 5y ago
> But I'll freely admit that having spent more than a decade as a network engineer my expectations may be weird.
I think you're correct in that regard. I'm an HPC administrator for ~15 years, and I manage quite a few systems with a sizeable storage and related network machinery up to a certain point. While I can understand your point, I've written my comment from the eyes of a bona fide standard consumer which doesn't do anything higher end on their homes.
> 40GB is overkill, but 10GB still bottlenecks for me. I'm surprised to see anyone consider 1GB a sweet spot-- it can't keep up with a single conventional disk, and it's causes obvious slowdowns for fairly conventional operations.
My sweet spot comment assumes streaming content consumption, occasional system to system file transfers, in home entertainment streaming and some gaming maybe. If I'd have to move my photography or video archive to a NAS instead of internal drives, a fatter network would be indeed required. To be bottlenecked by 10gbps, you really need to have a busy network with a lot of going on. None of my personal networks carry that amount of data any given time, and they don't need to do it to be honest. Moving 10gbps fairly constantly is not fairly conventional, TBH.
> I think that's a bit overstated. It's more fragile but not enormously so. Terminations are a nuisance, which favors pre-made patch cables. I'd pretty much always prefer to use 10g over fiber than copper.
Yes, modern fibers can endure relatively unbelievable amount of abuse, but it's still well inside the boundaries of a normal user's limits, and the threshold is still lower compared to fiber. Many people I know can damage a fiber without intending or knowing it.
> I used to use IB because the IB only nics were super cheap on ebay-- but I don't anymore. It's easy enough to use 10/40/100GBE. The extra software was a nuisance compared to the value it provided.
When you're doing HPC, the value provided by the features are indispensable. Latency, MPI offloading, DMA are all essential things you need for a really performing cluster. So we prefer IB rather than Ethernet. So horses for courses, obviously. I'd also rather not use IB for a home network.
> I mean, you can get 40gbe capable cards on ebay for like $50ish...
Consider the price as the money + setup + maintenance. For you, the last two items have no cost virtually. For me they'd be negligible. For a regular consumer, they're much bigger items to wrestle with.
So, as a people who knows how to play with bigger tools is really a privilege and luxury. However, I have enough servers at work, and I don't want to manage stuff at home. So if that lower and, dumb stuff works as I want and doesn't make my life worse, I'm a happy camper. As a result, I over-engineer my home stuff very minimally.