4 ms·
By your logic, someone that successfully guesses a weak password and ssh's into someone else's server and takes all of the data they can find there is doing not
by tsimionescu 5y ago
By your logic, someone that successfully guesses a weak password and ssh's into someone else's server and takes all of the data they can find there is doing nothing wrong, as they are "merely observing what their own computer was doing and making some TCP requests".
Obviously, this is not how the law sees it.
- nicomeemes 5y agoI don't think anyone here is disputing the fact that in the eyes of the law, his actions were illegal. But as someone who develops web scrapers/automation for a living, I poke and prod APIs in much the same manner as this guy. I don't feel such exploration should be criminalized. Sadly, it is. In your SSH scenario, its completely different- you're literally acting with the intent of accessing someone else's computer to exfiltrate sensitive data. That's not what happened here (according to the author).
- tptacek 5y agoRunning a crawler and poking around API artifacts manually simply aren't the same thing under the law, even though on the wire what's happening is the same. As long as your crawler isn't programmed to go looking for SQL injection vulnerabilities or whatever, there's no case to be made that you had any intent to gain unauthorized access. That's what matters here: your intent.