5 ms·
I don’t know, it might be a silly idea. But have you ever thought that parents should be responsible for their children? The only thing that the EU has done i
by scarface74 5y ago
I don’t know, it might be a silly idea. But have you ever thought that parents should be responsible for their children?
The only thing that the EU has done is make web browsing worse by forcing a damn cookie popup on every damn website.
- jdgoesmarching 5y agoParents can’t control the social landscape their children are born into. Sure, you can try to block the apps and socially isolate them if you care more about making a statement than their emotional wellbeing. Alternatively we can admit that there is an issue with the amount of power and influence given to a few companies who have privatized all normal communication, especially for the younger generation. There is a reality of psychological and sociological harm that can’t be mitigated by taking your children fishing and giving them a few stern lectures. Full grown adults can’t even fight being manipulated by these apps.
- alar44 5y agoRidiculous. The world is full of choices and kids need to learn how to make them. They don't learn that by being sheltered. And regarding power to a few companies: that's how it's always been.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- beachy 5y agoTry telling that to your 13 year old daughter when every one of her friend group is congregating on social app du jure.
- coryrc 5y agoYou are presumably an adult. Are your friends only within one year of age? Unlikely. That this happens for children is a consequence of our morally-bankrupt "education" system which isolates children away from the community and only with people the same age for socialization (of which teenagers are known to be poor at). The same way you can't blame an individual for not walking places in, say, Atlanta, because the path between two locations is interrupted by a highway; or you stop all fires from burning in a forest which has had fires for thousands of years then wonder why the fires are so intense; it's silly to point to social media being the primary issue why teens are bad at socializing when it's a direct consequence of your society to concentrate together people with wild hormones without a moderating influence.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoBeing a parent is all about teaching boundaries. I hated my parents for forbidding me to do things I wanted; from having a phone to not going to party when I was too young. I ended up having a phone and partying later on and I eventually came to hate both after a few years. Now that I grew up, I'm glad they stopped me from entering that world too early, I'm glad I tried and I'm glad I'm done with it.
- zpeti 5y agoAnd you’re getting downvoted. A very sad state of affairs that this post is what gets downvoted nowadays. Edit: perhaps ppl downvoting should ask their local psychologist about boundaries and why they’re important
- scarface74 5y agoYes because parents “setting boundaries” have stop kids from doing drugs, alcohol, having pre-marital sex, etc.
- scarface74 5y agoYou realize peer pressure has always been a thing right? We should have a “War on Social Media”, have the First Lady head a “Just Say No” campaign, and have commercials about “this is your brain on FaceBook”. Because that worked so well last time. But now, the government will get it right.
- adrianN 5y agoHumans in general are terrible at making choices. That's the whole reason every company needs a marketing department.
- LordDragonfang 5y ago...That reason being to encourage people to make bad choices which make the company money?
- adrianN 5y agoYes, of course.
- scarface74 5y agoSo are we going to outlaw everything that allows people to make bad choices about their own lives “for the children”?
- blowski 5y agoSo let children make a choice around fire or knives? I guess evolution will weed out the stupid ones right? Good parenting is partly about guiding our children to make good choices. This thread is discussing how we do that, and what good choices might look like.
- mellavora 5y agoparents vs marketing behemoths which also builds massive peer pressure. Wonder how that battle ends?
- shadowgovt 5y agoWith the creation of the He-Man She-Ra Christmas special.
- scarface74 5y agoSo all we need is the First Lady leading a “Just Say No” campaign since that worked so well fighting “peer pressure” about drug use. There has always been peer pressure and parents have mostly loss that battle. Even with government intervention.
- raffraffraff 5y agoThere's a balance. We don't let 13 year old kids drink alcohol, have sex, take drugs, drive cars, own guns, vote etc. Gradual exposure to responsibility, or harmful / addictive experiences isn't "sheltered", it's "responsible parenting". Jeez, I wouldn't even let my friend smoke "the strong weed" and he's 46. "Doom scrolling" didn't exist when I was a kid and I'm glad it didn't. I would never have developed a love of computers. The closest thing I had in the 80s was TV. 6 channels, and they all shut down at midnight and displayed a test signal. When they were "on" the content was mostly shit. Infinite scroll on social media is designed to be addictive. What chance does a 13 year old have when most adults (who have outgrown their teenage desperation for social acceptance) can't control that addiction? What happens when your kids is sent home from school because they assaulted someone or vandalized the school because it's a new cool thing on TikTok? Next they're yelling that the you're a bigot based on some obscure heuristic that doesn't even make sense? Ever tried using logic with someone who is 100% certain you're the bad guy because they've been brainwashed for 8 hours a day on an app? What was the big "social contagion" when you were growing up? For me it was music, slang and haircuts. These days it's self harm, coordinated vandalism, pornified ideas of bodies and sex. I know a lady who has a 16yo daughter who is bulimic... so are her whole clique.
- jokethrowaway 5y agoWhy does a 13 years old have access to social media? As you mention, we don't let kids drink alcohol at 13. My kids can call me a bigot and hate me as much as they want, it won't change the fact I am the parent and I decide what's right for them until they're of age. When I was growing up there was already vandalism, porn, unrealistic body image (bodybuilders for guys, anorexic models for girls), heavy underage drinking and goth cutting themselves. The only difference in today's world is that we celebrate people with mental illnesses for political purposes. Teaching your kids what the media say is mostly biased BS and forbidding them from using social media is not too hard.
- oblio 5y ago> Teaching your kids what the media say is mostly biased BS and forbidding them from using social media is not too hard. 1. Adults have pretty bad impulse control. 2. But kids or teenagers have even worse impulse control. 3. The prefrontal cortex, in charge of risk evaluation and decision making, matures when you're 25 years old (+/-). 4. These huge companies are built around addiction and getting network effects to set it. They have huge marketing budgets and a lot of money to lobby governments. What's I'm saying is: good luck getting the average kid to break a habit even many adults can't. And when the human brain, on average, fails ("don't drink and drive!"), we introduce laws to fix that. Personal responsibility only takes us so far, because we're human and fallible.
- scarface74 5y agoParents have been trying to outlaw things “for the children” all the way from rock n roll to rap music to video games Companies have not “privatized communication” besides “Facebook is for old people”. Are we going to have the government legislate the algorithms companies use? I bet politicians would love to say that companies must prioritize whatever speech they are in favor of.
- Vinnl 5y agoEven assuming that should be the case: how do you get that to happen? And if it doesn't happen, do we just sit back and do nothing?
- makeitdouble 5y agoWhat about the model where _society_ is responsible for children ? Imagine your kids play down the street, they’re about to go in an area with a lot of cars and a stranger passing by tells them its dangerous and go to the park ? Or your kids receive a ton of ads for gambling apps on youtube and you have recourse to make it stop instead of cutting your kids from the only viable video platform outside of tiktok ? Society is literally dead without children, why can’t it be safer for them in general ?
- nonrandomstring 5y agoI agree, but this stuff is like crack-cocaine. Until you've tried to separate kids from deliberately addictive tech it feels easy to just say "parents should take responsibility". They should. And as a parent I do. But parents need help. I watched a documentary about China where they have technology addiction boot camps. I supposed it would be biased toward "see what fascists the Chinese are...locking up kids for gaming too much", but within 5 minutes I changed my mind and could see a very different side. If parents give their kids smartphones and let them go wild on social media - because they feel unable to help their children against highly addictive behaviours - then they need societal backup and education to be better parents. It's hard enough just clothing and feeding those little ones. This stuff is destroying the lives of young people. And we made it! In my opinion, social media (and always-on smartphone culture) is bad for _everyone_ and should be treated as a public health issue like tobacco and alcohol. That way, governments can take a... like you know... _ACTUAL_ _MORAL_ position on it. Schools can be funded to message kids early and proprietors can feel emboldened to ban people from using technology in places (as in the UK where some pubs and gyms ban phones). We can get doctors and counsellors on board and fund public health awareness. The _real_ problem is governments are conflicted. They want social media. It's a useful surveillance and control mechanism. And to some degree a suppressant. I wrote a fair bit about here [1] [1] http://digitalvegan.net http://digitalvegan.net
- scarface74 5y agoHow has government regulating tobacco and alcohol worked out ? You remember that whole “Prohibition” thing don’t you?
- ben_w 5y ago> The only thing that the EU has done is make web browsing worse by forcing a damn cookie popup on every damn website. GitHub doesn’t have one. HackerNews doesn’t have one. The requirement is to get consent for unnecessary data processing, and most of the popups don’t even meet the requirements of GDPR to be non-coercive.
- scarface74 5y agoYet Stack Overflow does…
- ben_w 5y agoThat tells you SO is doing not-strictly-necessary data analytics. Which it admits directly when you click the cookie banner button labeled “Customise settings”: you are presented with four yes-no toggles, the first of which is labelled “Strictly Necessary” and which can’t be disabled. IANAL but from what I’ve been told the SO banner isn’t even GDPR compliant because it makes it harder to reject unnecessary cookies than to accept all of them.
- erik_seaberg 5y ago> That tells you SO is doing not-strictly-necessary data analytics. That tells me that they don’t know. Making every part of the org prove that they aren’t is very expensive but doesn’t improve the service.
- ben_w 5y agoThe customise settings popup has an always-on item literally labelled “Strictly Necessary”. If they apply that as on and everything else in that popup as off, they are in compliance with GDPR without having to show the popup. Unless that setting is misleading, but then they are not in compliance even despite showing the popup, even if they fix the problem I raised previously.
- scim-knox-twox 5y ago> The only thing that the EU has done is make web browsing worse by forcing a damn cookie popup on every damn website. No, GDPR requires consent. How it can be obtained is at the site administrator's decision. The GDPR even states that a lack of action (consent or refusal) cannot block further use of the site/app. Don't blame the EU for "cookie popups" because the whole situation is the fault of the site owners - they are implementing the requirements incorrectly.
- scarface74 5y agoSo whethee the law is bad or it is badly enforced - either way the government made life worse for people. See also the “War on Drugs”.