3 ms·
> I wonder if the court considered all this past evidence. What bearing do those other things have on whether or not this person complied with RedHat's tradema
by kelnos 5y ago
> I wonder if the court considered all this past evidence.
What bearing do those other things have on whether or not this person complied with RedHat's trademark requirements?
He may be an asshole, but that should have no bearing on matters of trademark law.
- kashyapc 5y agoFair point. I was wondering about it from an intention and misrepresentation point of view. To me, it's misleading to claim "we make Fedora" by a lone individual while the real "we" is thousands of contributors. Disclosure: I work for Red Hat, am an occasional Fedora contributor, but I have no dog in this hunt.
- parasense 5y agoBack in my days as an ambassador, I remember we had a principle: "Be Excellent". Probably wasn't a community rule, but more of a guideline... and, I think that principle has been violated here. I'm unclear of the domain owner's standing within the community, but as I've read more... it doesn't seem very excellent. I do believe there is a nexus of causality between community standing, and permission to use the trademark. However, just my opinion, actual trademark law may diverge.