7 ms·
A friend of mine got a bunch of stock options, and exercised them. Then they tanked. He got hit with a tax bill so large it more than wiped him out. His family
by WalterBright 5y ago
A friend of mine got a bunch of stock options, and exercised them. Then they tanked. He got hit with a tax bill so large it more than wiped him out. His family wound up in a trailer.
Moral 1: When exercising options, sell enough on the same day to pay the tax bill.
Moral 2: When dealing with large sums like that, consult with a CPA.
- evdubs 5y agoYour friend couldn't sell the shares and take a capital loss to offset the options gain?
- snypher 5y agoI think it is employee options, something like chunk of options convert to real shares (say $1m). Tax man asks hey, where's my eg $220k? Employee says it's ok, I have $1m (in shares). Something happens on the market and shares are now worth $0 (or sub-$220k). They still owe the $220k!
- systemvoltage 5y agoCan you not take $1M loss? At one point, you had owned $1M of stock. It went to $0. That's a personal loss of $1M.
- quickthrower2 5y agoTax years is the issue I assume
- trhway 5y ago[IANACPA] without 83b election the $1M gain on stock options on the moment of exercise goes into regular income while the $1M loss would go into capital loss. The limit on loss offset to the income is $3K/year. So in the first year there would be $997K of regular income to pay taxes from and $997K carry over loss. Without any other capital gains to use the loss against, it would take another 333 years to write that loss down.
- systemvoltage 5y agoExample from [1], emphasis mine. Suppose the stock market has a bad year. You sell a stock or mutual fund and realize a $20,000 loss with no capital gains that year. First, you'll use $3,000 of the loss to offset your ordinary income. The remaining $17,000 will carry over to the following year. Next year, if you have $5,000 of capital gains, you can use $5,000 of your remaining $17,000 loss carryover to offset it. You can use another $3,000 to deduct against ordinary income, which would leave you with $9,000. The remaining $9,000 will then carry forward to the next tax year. Assuming that you had no capital gains in the following three years, you could use up the remaining $9,000 loss, $3,000 at a time, over those three years. [1] https://www.thebalance.com/can-a-capital-loss-carryover-to-the-next-year-2388983 https://www.thebalance.com/can-a-capital-loss-carryover-to-t... The $3000 stacks as an additional deduction from income. But if you had capital gains of $100k, that can totally be offset with a remaining balance of $900k. You can chew away your capital loss carryover with capital gains faster than 333 years.
- thundergolfer 5y agoAt least in Australia, capital losses do not entitle you to a refund on taxes owed or paid. They just just offset subsequent capital gains.
- rocqua 5y agoThe 220k tax bill is on 'income' because it is employee compensation. The 1M loss is 'capital gains' and therefore a separate category which cannot offset against the 220k income tax bill.
- WalterBright 5y agoI think the problem was he didn't get the tax bill until the next tax year. Selling the stock at a loss that year would not offset the gain from the previous tax year.
- evdubs 5y agoWell I hope your friend tried to work with the IRS. At the very least they can put tax debtors on a payment plan, but I would think that they could grant an exception to your friend to have the gain and loss cancel each other out even if they took place during different accounting periods. Never hurts to ask.
- WalterBright 5y agoHe did reach a settlement with the IRS, after all, the debt was more than his net worth. But he still lost everything and wound up in a trailer.
- cl42 5y agoOof, this sounds awful. This obviously doesn't matter now, but my understanding is that call/put options are not taxable if you exercise them[1], rather they get included in the cost basis for whatever you end up owning once you exercise. I can see your friend losing lots of money due to the price fluctuations, but hopefully he didn't pay tax he didn't owe. I'm not a lawyer or accountant so if I'm wrong, happy to learn. :) [1] https://www.investopedia.com/articles/active-trading/053115/tax-treatment-call-put-options.asp https://www.investopedia.com/articles/active-trading/053115/...
- WalterBright 5y agoThey were employee stock options, not call/put ones. And yes, he had no idea he would owe tax on money he never had. His tax bill was way more than his net worth.
- exillustra 5y agoI believe there were Illustra engineers who exercised options shortly after the Informix acquisition at the end of 1995 (at $36/share) but either couldn't immediately sell shares or choose not to thinking the stock value would go up. They owed taxes on their gains (about $30/share) but shortly thereafter the stock crashed leaving the shares worth less then the taxes owed. The stock only continued to decline in value after Informix restated earnings and the extent of their channel stuffing became known. https://www.edn.com/toxic-accounting https://www.edn.com/toxic-accounting https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Informix_Corporation#Phil_White_indicted_and_pleads_guilty https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Informix_Corporation#Phil_Whit...
- cl42 5y agoThat really sucks. I hope your friend is doing better now. :(
- uranium 5y agoFolks here are likely talking about employee stock options [NSOs and ISOs]. They've each got their pitfalls, but generally if you exercise them, you immediately owe tax [or AMT, depending--talk to an accountant first!] on the difference between your strike price and the current fair market value. If your employer's public, you know what that value is and can generally sell to cover your taxes. If your employer is private, you need to find out what the FMV is from your employer, and you still owe tax on it [if there's a gain], but you likely have no way of selling to pay the taxes.
- cascom 5y agoWell on the bright side he at least gets to carry the ST loss forward (indefinitely?)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- brandmeyer 5y agoI've heard a variation on this that never quite made sense to me. Its possible that some relevant details were just lost in the retelling, and it goes like this: The employee exercised his options shortly after an IPO, but before he could sell the shares. By the time he could sell the shares, the stock had fallen to the point that the proceeds from sale didn't cover his taxes due. It wasn't enough to drive them to the poor house, but it was the difference between making money and losing money. Why would you exercise the options in this time window at all? What's the upside versus just sitting on them until the window opens up? Why would you even be able to exercise the options in the trading blackout window? Doesn't that count as trading itself? If both trades happened in the same calendar year, then wouldn't the capital loss from the sale wipe out the capital gain from the exercise, such that he only owed tax on the difference between the strike price and final sale price? What am I missing from this picture?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- WalterBright 5y agoIf you don't exercise them, you could lose them.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- thundergolfer 5y agoResignation can be a taxation event. If you’re getting taxed on the FMV of the options, you might as well lock in that price? You lose some cash, so that is a risk, but the big issue is taxation at resignation without liquidity. In Australia taxation at resignation stops being a thing on July 1st, thank god.
- toast0 5y ago> Why would you even be able to exercise the options in the trading blackout window? Doesn't that count as trading itself? Exercising options isn't prohibited during a trading blackout, because it's not a market transaction. (Especially if you're only exercising with no sell to cover). If your options are ISO, and you want to get the best tax treatment, it must be at least two years from grant and one year from exercise. If you joined around a year before the IPO, and you wanted the nice tax treatment, but to sell as soon as possible, then exercising near the IPO makes sense. If you do sell in the same tax year (which isn't always a calendar year, many companies and some people have adjusted their tax year), then it's a capital loss (and a disqualified disposition), etc. But if the IPO is later in the tax year, the blackout may extend beyond, and you'ld owe AMT in one year, and maybe realize a big loss in the next. If you realized a big gain in the next year, you'd also get a big AMT credit, and things would work out; but the AMT credit isn't refundable, so it could take many years to get that back, more if you also lost your job because the company imploded.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwawaybae420 5y agoWhy do people pay taxes that put them in real risk? Isn't the point of taxes to contribute financially to the continuance of the place that is doing something for you? I currently owe like 5 years worth of taxes, but paying it would compromise my well-being, so they can wait. Seems perfectly rational. If you have 50000 to pay in taxes, but only 10000 in savings and $3k a month in expenses, or even $50k in savings, only a small amount should be legally required from you. Maybe the U.S is different. Not to say I'm not working on it though, but if paying taxes would put me on the street, guess what, I'm not paying them until whatever they pay for lets me live a life. Just like any other debt, if I'm put in a vulnerable position, debts don't get paid unless they someone else owns the thing I'm living in or depend on, or they can break my legs, like the bank. One could argue you shouldn't have made that particular risky financial move, or you shouldn't be taxed on reception of illiquid assets, which would also both be valid.
- noodlesUK 5y agoI have no idea where you're writing this from, but in almost any western country that I have any knowledge about what you're describing is wilfully committing a crime.
- ShivShankaran 5y agoIt's a crime only in US. Most civilized countries allows people to stagger their taxes.
- jonas21 5y agoIn the US, it's not a crime as long as you file your taxes accurately. The IRS generally allows you to set up a payment plan or even settle for less than is owed if it would cause hardship to pay.
- toss1 5y agoRight, but you DO need to file the tax returns with the IRS, accurately reporting your income, and then actually negotiate the payment plan (and stick to it or renegotiate). We don't just get to unilaterally declare that 'I'll be uncomfortable paying taxes, so it can wait'... and then not bother to file or negotiate a plan, which seems to sum up OP's position. Wish him/her luck, they'll need it!
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- vishnugupta 5y ago> When exercising options, sell enough on the same day to pay the tax bill. That assumes the stock is trading publicly or at least you can legally sell them. In India most of the companies ask you to exercise your options within 2-3 months of quitting job. And most of them are not public companies. So there's a big dilemma. Exercise and take tax hit and hope that the company goes public and doesn't tank post IPO. Don't exercise and possibility of big regret. So..sort of a bummer. Ironically (and sadly) two of the most publicised IPOs in India (PayTM and Zomato) have tanked since their IPO.
- llampx 5y agoIPOs are a game of "let the institutional investors exit and leave retail holding the bag" I'm not investing in any IPOs unless it's at fire sale prices, and I know my line in the sand where I will take a loss rather than hope and pray.
- throw0101a 5y ago> IPOs are a game of "let the institutional investors exit and leave retail holding the bag" The Rational Reminder podcast had an episode on them a little while ago: > We’ve previously compared IPOs to lotteries that are prone to inflated valuations and low returns. Today we welcome “Mr. IPO,” Professor Jay Ritter onto the show for a deeper dive into IPO performance, for his insights into SPACs, and to hear his research into why economic growth doesn’t correlate with stock returns. Early in the episode, Jay unpacks how long-term IPO returns perform against first-day trading. While exploring the role that venture capital plays in tech IPOs, Jay talks about why negative earnings don’t affect tech IPOs in the short-term before sharing how skewness factors tend to impact young companies. Reflecting on how IPOs are usually underpriced, Jay discusses how the interests of companies are not aligned with the interests of IPO underwriters. After looking into IPO allocation, Jay compares the 2020 ‘hot IPO market’ with the internet bubble of the late 90s. Later, we ask Jay about what special-purpose acquisition companies (SPACs) are and why they’ve exploded in recent years. His answers highlight their investing benefits, risks, and why SPACs might be a better option for companies than IPOs. We examine how SPACs have historically performed and then jump into our next topic; why economic growth isn’t a good indicator that a country is worth investing in. He touches on why returns don’t correlate with economic growth, the place of capital gains and dividend yields when investing abroad, and how innovations in an industry can lead to higher stock returns. We wrap up our conversation by asking Jay for his take on whether the stock market is efficient before hearing how he defines success in his life. Tune in to hear our incredible and informative talk with Jay Ritter. * https://rationalreminder.ca/podcast/139 https://rationalreminder.ca/podcast/139 They're generally not a good idea unless you're on 'the inside' and can get early access.
- glenngillen 5y agoFormer boss told me a similar story from the first dotcom. He worked at Sun, things were looking great, a bunch of people vested and were paper millionaires. Two days later the market imploded and they were wiped out. He was one of the few who actually sold their equity straight away. Almost everyone else on his team now had a huge tax bill and nothing to pay it with. They went from thinking they were millionaires to bankrupt in less than a week.
- lizknope 5y agoThat didn't happen to me but I know multiple people in the same situation after the dot com collapse of 2000. https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2001-apr-13-mn-50476-story.html https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-2001-apr-13-mn-50476...
- shagie 5y agoI had this situation back in the dot com crash. I sold 2000 options in June. The following April I had to sell 15,000 to pay the taxes on the 2000. The following April I had to sell another 10,000 to pay the taxes on the 15,000. If I had sold 20,000 instead of 2,000 and used that to pay taxes, I would have been in a far better financial situation. Fortunately, I never went into the red, but I know people who did.