3 ms·
> Red states tend to have a much higher population of black residents, a group that is well established to have much higher crime rates. Black people are 13% of
by wolverine876 5y ago
> Red states tend to have a much higher population of black residents, a group that is well established to have much higher crime rates. Black people are 13% of the national population but commit 52% of the murders.
Expanding this to causation - that black people cause more crime - is not only a complete misuse of statistics - nothing there shows correlation, much less causation - it is an old racist saw. For example, a society which relegates people based on their skin color to poverty, lack of access to jobs, education, and healthcare, and continual discrimination, might be the causal agent. It could be that people in poverty, with poor educations, and difficult employment, are correlated with crime (but we'd need to look that up).
> Many of those red states have very liberal DAs who are refusing to prosecute certain crimes, asking for extremely low bail, and pursuing very short prison sentences, while also aggressively prosecuting alleged police misconduct.
Those DA's seem less prevelant in red states - is there some correlation there? And do you have evidence that these things increase crime rates? Most of the research says otherwise, the opposite practices had little impact for many years, and the people most affected by crime vote for these DAs.
- legalcorrection 5y agoThe correlation with race holds even when you control for poverty and other socioeconomic factors (such as urban/rural). But of course, you can't control for the unique historical experience of black Americans. So this remains an open question.
- wolverine876 5y agoSo what are you saying the causal relationship is, beyond the racist assertion that skin color causes crime?