3 ms·
I think this is getting long and no longer really productive. So this will be my last. "I don't think there's anything resembling evidence, or even a theoretic
by giantg2 5y ago
I think this is getting long and no longer really productive. So this will be my last.
"I don't think there's anything resembling evidence, or even a theoretical model for criminal behaviour, suggesting that is the case"
I haven't looked for any, nor do I know of any contrary. It's just my theory.
"I don't think there's anything resembling evidence, or even a theoretical model for criminal behaviour, suggesting that is the case"
That is the model for certain prohibitions. You can buy a handgun at 21, that's assuming you didn't commit any crimes. I'd you have a juvenile offense you can buy a gun at 35 if you have no further offenses (in my state). You can have most convictions expunged after 10 years of good behavior. The idea is that if you are clear for that long, then you must be rehabilitated or no longer a threat.
"--certainly not for crimes of passion, which are often not committed by people of all ages who hadn't previously murdered at any point in their lifetime."
The distribution seems to show otherwise. It's much more common from 18-40 than in other age groups.
https://www.statista.com/statistics/251884/murder-offenders-in-the-us-by-age/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/251884/murder-offenders-...
- cbsmith 5y ago> The idea is that if you are clear for that long, then you must be rehabilitated or no longer a threat. No, it does not mean that you are no longer a threat. It means that you are no longer more a significantly greater threat than the general population. Again, particularly with crimes of passion, someone who has never been a threat their entire life becomes a threat in a heart beat. > The distribution seems to show otherwise. It's much more common from 18-40 than in other age groups. That is not the age distribution of murders that were crimes of passion. That's the distribution of murders. The cluster with younger folks are no doubt those with a disproportionate propensity for murder/violence in general. But hey, that's an age distribution that one would expect if there was some base probability for murder based on interpersonal interactions! ;-)