5 ms·
Here are the first two paragraphs on the MMT Wikipedia article: > Modern Monetary Theory or Modern Money Theory (MMT) is a heterodox[1] macroeconomic theory th
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
Here are the first two paragraphs on the MMT Wikipedia article:
> Modern Monetary Theory or Modern Money Theory (MMT) is a heterodox[1] macroeconomic theory that describes currency as a public monopoly and unemployment as evidence that a currency monopolist is overly restricting the supply of the financial assets needed to pay taxes and satisfy savings desires.[2][3] MMT is opposed to the mainstream understanding of macroeconomic theory, and has been criticized by many mainstream economists.[4][5][6]
> MMT says that governments create new money by using fiscal policy and that the primary risk once the economy reaches full employment is inflation, which can be addressed by gathering taxes to reduce the spending capacity of the private sector.[7] MMT is debated with active dialogues about its theoretical integrity,[8] the implications of the policy recommendations of its proponents, and the extent to which it is actually divergent from orthodox macroeconomics.[9]
Regarding this being a "test" of MMT, I don't see why. The first part of the first sentence of that second paragraph, MMT says that governments create new money by using fiscal policy and that the primary risk once the economy reaches full employment is inflation, which seems to be precisely what has happened, no?
- IncRnd 5y ago> ...and that the primary risk once the economy reaches full employment is inflation, which seems to be precisely what has happened, no? Certainly, there is inflation. There isn't full employment.
- OGWhales 5y agoMMTers argue that government spending at full employment will cause inflation, not that there must be full employment for there to be inflation.
- dlp211 5y agoInflation has many inputs and looking at inflation strictly through a monetary lens will provide a distorted picture as to why there is inflation. Additionally, MMT states that it needs to use taxes to manage inflation, which the US federal gov't is clearly not doing, which undermines the testability of the theory.
- zemptime 5y agoMMT has seemed to me to be an academic fig leaf over the indirect taxation which occurs when more money is printed. MMT is fundamentally wrong, and everyone smart knows it is, but you as an individual can't make any sort of "respected" career as an economist unless you say the right things or are stupid enough to believe them.
- ericmay 5y agoAren't there record job openings? I know "full employment" is a loaded term here, but at least in a general sense all who want a job could at least find something right? One thing I'd be interested in seeing a discussion on as it relates to this topic is what happens when there is a legitimate labor shortage.
- Mountain_Skies 5y agoNot all job openings exist with the intention of ever being filled.
- standeven 5y agoHow do you define full employment? The unemployment rate in the USA is currently 3.8%.
- ummonk 5y agoThere's no strict definition, but an unemployment rate <4% almost certainly corresponds to full employment, as frictional unemployment can be expected to be ~4%.
- IncRnd 5y agoBLS defines full employment as an economy in which the unemployment rate equals the nonaccelerating inflation rate of unemployment (NAIRU), no cyclical unemployment exists, and GDP is at its potential. [1] [1] https://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2017/article/full-employment-an-assumption-within-bls-projections.htm https://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2017/article/full-employment-an...
- chimeracoder 5y ago> How do you define full employment? The unemployment rate in the USA is currently 3.8%. 3.8% is near historic lows. More importantly: "full employment" doesn't mean unemployment is literally 0% - in fact, an unemployment rate of 0% would be actively bad, because it indicates that people are unable to leave their jobs (even temporarily) to seek better opportunities or life changes - usually because inflation is too high.
- drexlspivey 5y agoUnemployment < 4% is basically full employment. People that are changing jobs are temporarily unemployed. Another metric you can use to reach the same conclusion is that # of job openings > unemployed work force
- IncRnd 5y agoThat's U-3. U-6 is at 7.2%. In general the claim that many people are not returning to work after COVID lockdowns is true. The reasons are up for debate, but that's not the point. The U-3 rate is an artificial rate to claim as the truth. That's moving the goal posts in order to get the win. Plus there are a record number of unfilled job openings.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hn_throwaway_99 5y agoYour argument is a non sequitur to me: > Plus there are a record number of unfilled job openings. Yes, which would basically imply that it's incredibly easy for anyone who wants a job to get one.
- IncRnd 5y ago> Your argument is a non sequitur to me: For something to be a non sequitur, it must be a non sequitur to everyone, not just to one. This is not a non sequitur for two reasons. 1) The sentence you quoted was not intended to be a consequence of the earlier statement. Unemployment rate and number of job openings are connected, but not as you believe. Correlation is not causation. You are drawing inferences without cause. 2) Full employment depends upon the number of job openings as well as the unemployment rate, which you ignored from my comment. > Yes, which would basically imply that it's incredibly easy for anyone who wants a job to get one. No. That is your inference but is clearly not implied.
- bskap 5y agoU-6's 7.2% is compared to 7.0% in February 2020 and 8.1% in February 2007. So even that is similar to pre-Covid levels and better the the peak before the last recession.
- germinalphrase 5y agoWouldn’t it also suggest that the prescribed inflation antidote - raising taxes - would be impractical due to political opposition. Seems like a double win: stand strong against raising taxes (which is the heterodox position) while showing MMT “doesn’t work”.
- ece 5y agoA few years ago, Janet Yellen (testifying in congress I believe) called for more research into "hot" economies because presumably there was a lack of such research. We're now in a period of growth and basically full employment after a pandemic where the fed and fiscal policy decided to keep things "hot." There have also been supply and energy shocks that are contributing to inflation. The remaining part of the MMT puzzle as I see it is: raise corporate taxes, and see if it helps bring inflation under control. If raising rates slowly doesn't quite do it, this should be the next go to for policy makers.
- mudlus 5y agoAll value is explanatory, that is, even if it has "intrinsic value" like carbohydrates in ATP in a cell, it is still knowledge instantiated for a resilient purpose (eg to power a cell to replicate its knowledge). As explanations change, value changes, so anything can be a currency at the level of the individual--in this way, at least for conscious minds, a public monopoly on money is, while possible, morally wrong. It's a form of Marxism. There's already been a solution the problem of state monopoly on symbolic abstractions for value (money), that started with Bitcoin and has been growing a new global economy since 2009.
- xxpor 5y agoThe state has a monopoly on money because they collect taxes. Try paying your taxes in BTC and tell me how that goes.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- landemva 5y agoWhat do you mean by, 'Try paying your taxes in BTC ...' ? In USA, sales taxes are paid to government by the vendor. As just a typical person in USA who does not work for federal government nor reside in D.C., sales taxes and property taxes are all that I (implicitly) pay. The vendor and I determine amount and type of my payment. Your comment had a threatening tone implying something bad may happen. What is the lurking threat?
- xxpor 5y agoYou don't pay federal income taxes?
- landemva 5y agoMany people don't qualify to pay 'income' tax, but most people just think they have to do it. And employers withhold it from wage slave paychecks, which does make it challenging to opt out. Definitely possible to not have what is known as wage income. Many do it. The super rich structure their affairs to avoid being in that system of voluntary contributions.
- bitshiftfaced 5y ago> and that the primary risk once the economy reaches full employment is inflation, which can be addressed by gathering taxes to reduce the spending capacity of the private sector. I don't understand this. Increasing taxes reduces the spending power of the individuals who pay the taxes. But that taxed money doesn't evaporate. The government spends it or redistributes it. It ultimately makes its way back into the private sector.
- brimble 5y agoThe key concept is that taxation is unrelated to the government's ability to spend (with fiat currency). They can tax $1T and spend $1T. Or they can tax $0 and spend $1T. Government is not constrained from spending whatever amount it likes—except in the spending's effects on money supply, inflation, et c. From that POV, destroying money (or, if you prefer, reducing the rate of increase in the money supply) is exactly what taxation does.