4 ms·
>The church knew this would set people thinking. This sentence carries a lot of weight and I don't think it's terribly truthful, or at best, speculative. Gali
by llbeansandrice 5y ago
>The church knew this would set people thinking.
This sentence carries a lot of weight and I don't think it's terribly truthful, or at best, speculative.
Galileo wasn't in trouble with the church because "it would get people thinking". He was in trouble because he was directly opposing the power and teachings of the church. Whether people would "think" about it I don't feel is terribly relevant, let alone something you can definitively say. Do we really know that the church was worried people would "think for themselves", or just that.
This implication is that the church knew Galileo was right. It also implies that these "things you can't say" are universally good and beneficial to society. With falsehoods neatly hand-waved away by conflating them with "people in Pittsburgh are 10 feet tall". Well, people believe the earth is flat, vaccines cause 5G, that Donald Trump won the 2020 election, and a whole host of other things that are harmful to society in varying degrees.
Being shunned for your ideas isn't evidence that you are Galileo leading the world into a bright new future. More likely you are, at best, the eccentric who should be ignored and your idea is that people in Pittsburgh are 11 feet tall.
- apocalypstyx 5y agoEven this isn't correct. The only thing the Church told Galileo was that he couldn't state his hypothesis as fact. And this was correct; the science/technology to prove the hypothesis was not yet extant. (We tend to misapply our own hindsight here.)
- nme01 5y agoGood remark. Many people believe that Galileo was burned but it’s simply not true (I don’t even know where it comes from). IIRC the most serious punishment he got was a home-arrest which he got after being rude to pope (which he was after he was forbidden to state his hypothesis as fact). Also as a side note: Galileo didn’t form a hypothesis good enough as it predicted planets’ movements poorly. It was Kepler who formed much more accurate model and it got accepted by the Church. There are also some other misbelieves about the Church like that they forbidden spreading the theory of evolution (while in fact they forbade priests to criticize it openly).
- Yoofie 5y agoIf someone wants to get better informed about such common myths like you mentioned, what books or material should I read?