3 ms·
So how come you can independently re implement an API but if you try and do that with a hard good and slap a ford mustang badge you reimplemented independently
by asdff 5y ago
So how come you can independently re implement an API but if you try and do that with a hard good and slap a ford mustang badge you reimplemented independently onto it you get sued? Further more this is software. Why can't the team looking at the source code just write up the new code rather than write up a spec? Seems like such a useless performance considering you could just run a diff or something to catch plaigerism.
- ghaff 5y agoBecause if you basically just rename variables and some other lazy obfuscations, it's still a copyright violation. This isn't about efficiency. It's about using a process that's relatively resistant to legal challenge.
- BaseballPhysics 5y ago> do that with a hard good and slap a ford mustang badge you reimplemented independently onto it you get sued? Ah, now we're getting into a completely different forms of IP protection. The Ford Mustang badge is a protected trademark, so you're not allowed to use it without their permission. The car itself might also contain patented technical or design elements that you may not be allowed to duplicate without a license. Broadly there's four classes of IP protection out there: copyrights, patents, trademarks, and trade secrets. This discussion vis a vis reverse engineering is primarily centered around copyright protections. As for the rest of your comment, check out my other reply where I hopefully clarified things.