3 ms·
This is more evidence for why I think the "Vulnerable World Hypothesis" is not only a real framework, but that it describes the most eminent danger to society.
by echelon 5y ago
This is more evidence for why I think the "Vulnerable World Hypothesis" is not only a real framework, but that it describes the most eminent danger to society. It's far more dangerous than nuclear MAD, in my opinion.
We're entering into a future where average educated people will be able to synthesize biochemical agents, delivery mechanisms, viruses, and more. I've thought up half a dozen low-hanging fruit that I think anyone could build today. You can probably do the same if you think about it.
You don't even have to attack humans. Our society is dependent on a lot of assumptions.
And just as VWH states, I don't think it can be defended against. It's scary.
- qq66 5y agoI don't even think you need a hostile actor, you could just have an incompetent actor who flips the sign on a value, and instead of designing a biological agent to maximize wheat production, designs one that minimizes wheat production, and ends up exterminating all global wheat.
- spicybright 5y agoTo be fair, at least for your example, you'd need a really long chain of incompetent actors to kill off wheat. We should really be scared of the lone and bored grad student making a wheat killer and accidentally dropping the test tube.
- astrange 5y agoI'd be more worried about someone developing a plastic-recycling microbe that works too well. There's already lots of viruses that attack plants, but the plants have immune systems for that.
- echelon 5y agoDegrading plastics would be a nasty one. On the topic of plants, instead of attacking crops directly, attack mycorrhiza. Plants can't get nutrients without them.
- webmaven 5y ago> I'd be more worried about someone developing a plastic-recycling microbe that works too well. See the 2007 novel Ill Wind by Kevin Anderson and Doug Beason for an exploration of this scenario: https://books.google.com/books/about/Ill_Wind.html?id=wWIgO72HZXoC https://books.google.com/books/about/Ill_Wind.html?id=wWIgO7...
- muaytimbo 5y agoIt's not trivial to synthesize VX-like compounds without killing yourself. You would definitely need an "above average" educated/trained person.