5 ms·
David Graeber's "Debt: the first 5000 years" makes a fairly coherent case that the first instance of interest-accruing debt [EDIT: I had called this usury, but
by PaulDavisThe1st 5y ago
David Graeber's "Debt: the first 5000 years" makes a fairly coherent case that the first instance of interest-accruing debt [EDIT: I had called this usury, but that implies unethical, which is tangential to the point] inevitably leads to an economic requirement for conventional economic growth.
The borrower must pay the lender more than was borrowed. The only way to accomplish this is to do something that is essentially always considered to be "growth" by economists.
I didn't accept this argument when I first heard it, but I spent at least 2 days debating it while hiking in Scotland, trying to find ways around it, and ultimately accepted that it seems completely true.
- Aperocky 5y agoIt could also be inflation...
- nostrademons 5y agoIn theory lenders are supposed to set their rates to get the desired real return. If inflation is 10% they'll add 10% to their rates to make sure they stay ahead of it. (This actually happened in the 1970s, and is a major reason why rates were so high.)
- Aperocky 5y agoTheory is great but my radio station is filled with ads about loan rates that starts with 2.
- nostrademons 5y agoYes, and this is a great opportunity for profiting at a lender's expense.
- uoaei 5y agoMoney is a lot freer than it was.
- rank0 5y agoI think you’re missing the OPs point. He’s saying that the ability to lend and borrow with interest is a fundamental precondition for human economies. That’s why economic growth is not optional. Just look at the past 100 years. We have observably created tremendous value since 1922. We can make the whole pie bigger, it’s not just one set “value” pie that never changes.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoActually, the opposite point: once you lend/borrow with interest, you are locked into a cycle of "conventional economic growth" that is extremely difficult to escape from. The argument/debate described in TFA is that we may or do need to escape from this cycle; my point was that if Graeber's argument is correct, this is made all the more difficult by the presence of interest-bearing debt.
- dasil003 5y agoYes, this makes perfect sense if we assume everything has a fixed value over time. If you trade one pig now in exchange for two later, obviously more work will need to be done to raise two compared to what was originally done to raise one. However once you introduce currency into the equation the nominal value is de-coupled from actual value of goods. I think that's what GGP is getting at: doesn't inflation provide exactly the escape hatch where you can nominally charge interest but still not have true economic growth?
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoWell ... If there's inflation but no corresponding increase in the monetary supply, it becomes more difficult (in aggregate) to pay for things, which means that "actual economic growth" becomes necessary to pay the debt. If there's inflation and a corresponding increase in the monetary supply (e.g. where banks just print money and prices rise, in either order), then (in theory) paying off the debt becomes easier. If there's an increase in the monetary supply but no inflation, then (in theory) paying off the debt becomes easier. However, all these scenarios are unusual: in general, inflation is assumed to be controlled, and roughly known, and the interest rate will already include the assumed rate of inflation. When things go upside down w.r.t. inflation, you can certainly get unusual conditions around debt. But that's not the normal situation, even when there is actual inflation.
- rank0 5y agoDoesn’t “usury” have a predatory connotation? I think just the concept of debt is what has allowed our human economy/society to develop. Nobody would ever be able to start a business without debt. (Unless you’re already rich) Nobody would ever just hand out their capital for free. There has to be an incentive for the lender to take on the risk of default, and so we make agreements that interest be paid to the lender. Healthy, responsible lending is truly a win-win for everyone. Usury is like payday loans and shit credit cards targeting poor college students. Things where the lender knows the borrower will be unable to pay and thus trapped forever
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoFair point. I've edited my original post. I was not aware that "usury" always has an unethical connotation.
- dredmorbius 5y agoThe original definition was interest earned on money leant. It's not the practice but the definition which has narrowed.
- polar0bear 5y ago
- dredmorbius 5y agoGraeber's argument is interesting but it's always bothered me a bit. Monetary wealth is societally and legally recognised claims on wealth or production. It is ultimately a form of information, and a form of information that is specifically a relation between the individual (or other legal entity) and the societal wealth at large. There is no inherent conservation law or other limitation on this, an as recent international responses to actions have noted, that recognition can be withdrawn, to both financial wealth and property, should a society (or its oligarchical / plutocratic / autocratic ruling class) decide to do so. The backstop to demand for money in a fiat economy is new money creation through a central bank. Should banks lose money on net on loans, it might be that the least worst is recognised as the best performer, and others liquidated or re-liquified through central bank actions. Debts themselves can be inflated away (this usually causes the least dislocation), discharged through bankruptcy, or simply defaulted on (in the case of sovereigns --- see various national debt defaults, and several state defaults in the US prior to the 1940s). Debt expires on death of persons in most modern countries. The estate may remain liable, but inheritors are not. Inflation is the general predisposition, but not the only option.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoThere's a lot in "Debt" to help explain that debt itself precedes the concept of money. What Graeber discusses in relation to the connection between interest-bearing debt and economic growth doesn't have much to do with contemporary financial arrangements or institutions, but the very basic point: the borrower must return to the lender more than was borrowed. It doesn't really matter what was lent, or what is returned, and it almost doesn't matter what the notion of property is at the time, as long as it remains consistent across the life of the loan.
- dredmorbius 5y agoI get that. And on average for loans which are repaid that is true. But the concept speaks to a "limited supply of money" theory which does not in fact exist. There are loans which are not repaid, which are subject to default, to bankruptcy, in which the debtor dies before the loan is repaid, etc., and for which the creditor ultimately writes off the balance. Under a growing economy, that doesn't occur at a rate which exceeds total loan revenues --- moneylending is a net-positive activity. And I will grant that virtually all post-WWII economics is premised on the notion that total wealth will and does grow, which is wired into all sorts of models, laws, policies, and practices. But it is not necessarily the case, and a fiat currency system can in fact address this directly. (Much will have to change for this to be the case, but it's not inherently impossible.) This does create a huge vested interest in perpetual-growth ideologies. Again, I don't deny this. But again, it does not necessitate this.
- snowwrestler 5y agoIt seems like a logical way of thinking about it, but I think it would be a mistake to conclude that debt causes economic growth. Because why did the borrower need to take out a loan in the first place? Seems like the chicken and the egg to me.