3 ms·
> I don't see them as having contempt for democracy. Lenin's slogan, after all, was 'all power to the soviets'. Do you usually just straight up buy propaganda
by panick21_ 5y ago
> I don't see them as having contempt for democracy. Lenin's slogan, after all, was 'all power to the soviets'.
Do you usually just straight up buy propaganda served to you by dictators?
> I also think that it's normal to have a democratic deficit during an extremely chaotic situation, and a lot of the people 'standing in the way of their ideals' were also trying to kill the Bolsheviks.
Yes, but many were not in the way of 'all power to the soviets' but the Bolsheviks killed them anyway.
> German armies were literally rolling through Russia at the time.
German are the ones that helped put the Bolsheviks into power. This is well known fact. And not just transport, but also money and political protection.
> It's also the case that leftists simply have a different definition of democracy to liberals.
Yes, the Bolsheviks definition of democracy of 'democracy' was 'what the people want' and the way to figure that out was to consult their own opinions.
So whatever Stalin/Lenin or later Mao wanted was by definition 'democratic'.
Everybody else calls that sort of thing a dictatorship, but I guess if you are far enough left you can transform language to use all the popular words to fit whatever you want to do.
> I don't think you can simply call them anti-democratic on the simple grounds that their idea of democracy differs from yours.
Yes actual that's exactly what you should do. Because we can not allow a group of extremist to simply change definitions of words that actually had a meaning for 1000s of years.
Do you also accept the Nazi opinion that they were Socialist? Do you just accept anything violent groups say in their propaganda?
At the end of the day, call it whatever you want, all this arguments about semantics is pointless. The simple fact is, they wanted power and control. And they killed literally everybody who opposed them. Its that simple and its fundamentally evil.