3 ms·
Is this actually saying anything new, except for putting it in the language of economics and markets? How does this differ from say Hitler's "Big Lie" or adver
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
Is this actually saying anything new, except for putting it in the language of economics and markets?
How does this differ from say Hitler's "Big Lie" or advertising or propaganda generally or 1984's memory hole.
I'm not sure the weasel words around "fake news" are required. If someone is misinformed by their news source, are we really splitting hairs that it isn't misinformation if they just don't mention certain things because that's not a false fact?
Wasn't the whole point of Newspeak that you couldn't mention or discuss certain ideas?
- meekmind 5y agoI think that intent matters. Misinformation is dissemination of information that may be misleading but wasn't necessarily intended to be misleading. Perhaps the author themselves lacked the pertinent data (or really believed what they were saying). That is distinct from disinformation, which would be intentionally deceptive. Regarding material omissions, it would only be misinformation if the person disseminating the information did so unknowingly. And hypothetically it would only take one person to inform the author of the material omission and naturally further publications with the same material omission then count as disinformation. I think the hair-splitting is due to the fact that majority of memes associated with one side or the other are not outright false, but are conditioning people to a particular pre-determined conclusion. In other words, if you're interested in battling mis/dis-information, you have to recognize the over-arching agenda and attack that, not rebut/censor every meme and thought internet randos and robots see fit to post.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoIt feels avit like the 'carbon footprint' thing. These arent propagandists telling lies to male moneu from human suffering, no theyrr just meeting a market demand for lies about clinate change. But then you have to ask, why did conservative politicians and voters switch suddenly to not believing it after initially accepting it as a fact. Tge obvious answer is that the fossil fuel interests paid then to lie. And so this 'market demand' was crested intentiobally by bad actors. Russia is currently acting as a live demonstration of right-wing thought gone wrong, so if we apply this lens to that situation then apparently all the people on state media lying about stuff are just responding to a market demand from Russian people to justify their nation being the good guy. But wouldn't it be cheaper to fill that need by actually being the good guy? So the propaganda is only needed when the populace want to believe one thing, but it's better for those in power to not do that, but deliver BS instead