3 ms·
If I'm a cop, and I suggest to you that we should go rob a bank tomorrow, and you actually show up at Main and Third to do it, that's not entrapment. That's jus
by vkou 5y ago
If I'm a cop, and I suggest to you that we should go rob a bank tomorrow, and you actually show up at Main and Third to do it, that's not entrapment. That's just you being a bank robber.
If I threaten you into doing it, that's entrapment. If I don't threaten you, and we talk about doing it, but you don't actually take any meaningful steps towards doing it, you're in the clear. If we talk about doing it, and you go out to buy a gun, and a ski mask, and find a driver for the getaway car, it's also not entrapment. Because you're taking meaningful steps towards carrying out a conspiracy.
Even if I'm the one selling you the gun. And the ski mask.
- dylan604 5y agoIt's still 100% total bullshit. For law enforcement to make any attempt at convincing someone to commit a crime so that they could then come in and make the arrest to solve the crime is absolutley something that should not be allowed. If I hire a hitman to do a deed, I go to jail more than the hitman. When a LEO convinces someone to do a crime, they need to go to jail too.
- vkou 5y agoNo, it's not. One of your responsibilities as a citizen is not getting involved in what you believe are serious criminal conspiracies. Another one is not getting involved in what actually are serious criminal conspiracies.
- dylan604 5y agoPeople that commit these crimes "suggested" by undercover typically aren't the sharpest tool in the box. For LEOs to take advantage of that is reprehensible. One of LEOs responsibilities shouldn't be to see how many crimes they can get others to commit on their behest. It should be to catch those that commit crimes. We don't need more crime because LEO encourages it. That's just bassakwards logic.
- mrslave 5y agoJerry Drake Varnell needed the assistance of 3 FBI agents: one to seduce him online, another to pose as a bomb expert, and a third to teach him to drive a car.
- zzo38computer 5y ago> One of LEOs responsibilities shouldn't be to see how many crimes they can get others to commit on their behest. It should be to catch those that commit crimes. We don't need more crime because LEO encourages it. That's just bassakwards logic. This is I agree. If someone else commit the crime then the police can arrest them. Police should not make other people to commit a crime, and the police should not commit their own crimes either. Even if they are the police, they should not be mean to everyone else, but too often there is too much police meanness.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- zzo38computer 5y agoI think that it depend on the circumstances; there are different kind of entrapment, that do different things. In some cases, the police should be arrested for such a thing, but whoever they tried to convince to do, can be freed due to a technicality. In some cases, both the police and whoever they told to do, should both be arrested for such a thing. In some cases, nobody need to be arrested. Sometimes, the police should be fired for such a thing but should not be arrested. Selling you a gun and ski mask does not necessarily mean that you will rob a bank. That isn't entrapment. In that case, if you do rob a bank then you can be arrested for it; whoever sold the gun and ski mask didn't make them rob a bank so they aren't the criminal. (Although, there might be a separate issue if purchasing a gun requires safety training (which it probably should, if it is a business transaction), and they don't have any; but, that is a separate issue.) But, if the police lie to you to make you to rob a bank instead, to try to make you to do so, then that is different; then the police is the one who is criminal.
- sirspacey 5y agoNo that is coercion. Entrapment is: “ An affirmative defense in which a defendant alleges that police officers acquired the evidence necessary to commence a criminal prosecution of the defendant by inducing the defendant to engage in a criminal act which the defendant would not otherwise have committed.” Of course, the debate is “not otherwise committed” but hypotheticals are not a basis for “beyond reasonable doubt.”
- watwut 5y agoI think that you are confusing coercion and entrapment. Which is quite worrisome coming from cop. If you are suggesting to someone to rob a bank tomorrow, then you are in fact creating the crime.