4 ms·
That idea has some quite surprising and arguably inconvenient consequences: https://qntm.org/abolish https://qntm.org/abolish Most notably, the concepts of "to
by lxgr 5y ago
That idea has some quite surprising and arguably inconvenient consequences: https://qntm.org/abolish https://qntm.org/abolish
Most notably, the concepts of "today" and "tomorrow" stop making sense!
- mcronce 5y agoThey already don't make sense when you're trying to coordinate communication with people more than a few timezones away
- colejohnson66 5y agoWhich defeats one of the supposed “benefits”: “meeting at 2PM” means the same everywhere.
- mcronce 5y ago"Meeting at X" means exactly what it always meant. The only difference made by removing timezones is that you don't need to adjust the time for remote dial-ins. 2PM becomes 2PM everywhere.
- caylus 5y agoIf we abolished time zones, it wouldn't make sense /ever/ for people in some parts of the world, even when communicating with people close to them. That's worse.
- mcronce 5y agoWhy wouldn't it make sense "ever" in any part of the world?
- caylus 5y agoIn some areas, standard workdays would span "days". So e.g. a business would need to post its hours as "M-F, 00:00 - 1:00, 17:00 - 24:00". (actually it's even worse as the last 00:00 - 1:00 is on a Saturday) Or imagine chatting with a friend at 23:00 about plans after you get off work at 1:00 the following "day". "See you tomorrow?" Or do you reserve "tomorrow" for telling someone at 8:00 that you'll get back to them when you wake up at 16:00 that same "day"? Today people only have to deal with this when communicating with people many time zones away, but now it's an issue even within a single area!
- imoverclocked 5y agoThat's already the case for people very far North/South. Summer/winter become their own day/night at the poles... according to the Sun. If you take a walk around the pole, you can cross several timezones and end back where you started while having "lost an hour" every few steps. Of course, in one of those crossings you "gain a day" so, watch your step!
- msla 5y agoMore to the point, you cease to be able to predict what people many miles away from you are doing: It's 6 AM in London. What time is it in Denver? The way things work now, it's approximately midnight in Denver, or close enough that the safe answer to the question "What is my business partner in Denver doing?" is "Sleeping" which neatly answers the question of what their likely response will be were I to call them now. Now, imagine we abolish time zones: It's 6 AM in London. What time is it in Denver? It's 6 AM. It's 6 AM in Beijing, in Cairo, in Honolulu, at McMurdo Station, and in Sidney, Montana. I have little idea what anyone in Denver is doing, unless I happen to know that Denver is placed such that their dawn is six-ish hours after mine. But I have no way to express that conveniently, and nobody else thinks in those terms, so I can't build up a database of such information. At least, not without reinventing something... It's 6 AM in London. What time is it in Denver? What would I be... It's 6 AM in London. Something occurs... The clock is striking thirteen. I almost... DENHAM'S DENTIFRICE! Consider the lilies of tzdata... DENHAM'S... Sorry, got a bit caught up there.
- majormajor 5y ago> It's 6 AM in London. What time is it in Denver? > The way things work now, it's approximately midnight in Denver, or close enough that the safe answer to the question "What is my business partner in Denver doing?" is "Sleeping" which neatly answers the question of what their likely response will be were I to call them now. Memorizing a timezone offset is basically still what you'd need to do. To know that it's approximately midnight in Denver, you have to have that memorized or look it up. Once you have that 6 hour number, in a single-timezone world, you'd simply say "ok what were people here doing 6 hours ago?" and you'd have your same answer. Of course people would still publish those sorts of "conversion tables"/offsets, because people would still have that exact problem! But they'd possibly be a bit more precise than historically - with current computer tech, it might actually be more accurate, e.g. using actual GPS coords instead of broad swaths, so it would be like "Denver is 6.24 (or whatever) hours behind your current location." Let alone how much better that might work for cities in single-timezone China, say. (I'm personally against this idea, anyway, but that particular argument has never satisfied me.)
- 5y ago