4 ms·
You’re playing fuck-fuck games with your arguments and not being honest. I could just as easily turn that argument around and say “why would the US want to sig
by refurb 5y ago
You’re playing fuck-fuck games with your arguments and not being honest.
I could just as easily turn that argument around and say “why would the US want to sign onto an agreement that include countries like Jordan and Cambodia that have no rule of law”?
- monocasa 5y agoWhich countries other than the US that don't welcome ICC authority do you think are doing it for noble goals?
- refurb 5y agoA better question is - which countries that did sign the Rome agreement will conveniently back out when one of their own citizens is up for charges that they don't agree with? The ICC is no different than the UN - an international body that is a convenient cover for powerful nations to cloak themselves in. Charges against African despots? Well Europe is on board for that! Charges for war crimes during the Afghan war? Whoa there! We never agreed to that!
- monocasa 5y agoNot really, because my question showed the false dichotomy in how you're trying to frame it. When all other countries we'd consider the closest things to paragons of democracy we have signed it, it paints a pretty clear picture. That picture remains clear even when despotic regimes are about 50/50 on it. Pointing in the direction of a hypothetical doesn't really change that. > Charges against African despots? Well Europe is on board for that! And Europeans as seen from the trials of the war crimes that occurred following the breakup of Yugoslavia. > Charges for war crimes during the Afghan war? Whoa there! We never agreed to that! And yet the ICC has been investigating war crimes during the Afghan war, until the US started sanctioning ICC employees. They have since restarted the investigations. https://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/prosecutor-seeks-resume-icc-probe-afghanistan-80255045 https://abcnews.go.com/International/wireStory/prosecutor-se...
- refurb 5y agoThat was a nice dodge of my counter-argument. By your own theory, since most “beacons of democracy” are a part of the UN, clearly they adhere to all decisions by that body? Of course they don’t. My point stands - if the ICC starts charging powerful members states citizens you’ll pretty quickly watch support crumble. That’s why the African countries are pulling out - it’s pretty clear how the court will be used and it won’t be pointed towards its most powerful members. Rather than join that circus, the US would rather bow out.
- monocasa 5y agoYou started off by calling someone a liar for misrepresenting the nature of the countries that are members. I'd appreciate if you at least finished one argument before shifting to another.
- refurb 5y agoSummarized: - OP was dishonest by listing only a few countries that haven't signed on - OP argument was "everyone else is doing it", which is not very convincing - My argument is the ICC is no different than the UN or other international bodies, their authority comes from the most powerful members, so you can guarantee the most powerful members won't play nice when they're in the crosshairs (as evidenced by the current countries' citizens being prosecuted are all minor powers)
- throwawaycities 5y ago> - OP was dishonest by listing only a few countries that haven't signed on I don’t think you know the definition of dishonest. One final time I list a number of countries that aren’t signatories to the Rome Statute, I never stated or implied that was an exhaustive list. >OP argument was "everyone else is doing it", which is not very convincing That is dishonest because that was not my argument and obviously inconsistent with the fact that I gave a list of countries that “were not doing it”. Lastly your argument fails in light of every other international body the US is a part of, every treaty the US is a part of, and every international law the US is subject to…the irony is that is my argument. Moreover, your argument is “the ICC is no different than the UN or other international bodies” and the US isn’t part of the ICC. because “powerful countries won’t play nice”. If you don’t see where your logic breaks down, try to answer why the US is a member to all the other international bodies you claim are “no different” than the ICC, and the US is part of those other bodies but not the ICC.