5 ms·
There's a third faction: People who believe that it should be possible for a society to agree on things just starting an hour earlier (or later) where it makes
by lxgr 5y ago
There's a third faction: People who believe that it should be possible for a society to agree on things just starting an hour earlier (or later) where it makes sense, all without literally touching a single clock.
Introducing a (permanent, i.e. unlike DST) offset to solar time just seems like a ridiculous solution to any real or perceived problem.
- thomasahle 5y ago> it should be possible for a society to agree on things just starting an hour earlier How would that ever work? I can't think of a single thing requiring near that level of coordination that we are able to do. Automatically changing peoples closed seems infinitely easier. I understand some people don't like it, but don't pretend there is another way to move everything around. People are barely willing to do it as is.
- lxgr 5y agoWhy does it have to be a centrally coordinated shift? This is a decision that can be done in a decentralized way. Outdoor venues already have seasonally shifting time tables. Schools in some places have successfully shifted from starting at 8:00 to 7:30 or 8:30. Shops adjust their opening hours all the time as well.
- cameldrv 5y agoBecause actions in society have to be coordinated and done in a certain order. What happens when suddenly your kids school starts an hour later but you still have to be at work at the same time? Many many things are based on routines at a set time each day that people plan for. If there’s going to be a seasonal change, it needs to be coordinated to not cause massive inconvenience. That’s what DST does.
- hamandcheese 5y agoThe argument is basically "if the state-sponsored babysitters change their hours partway through the year it will be a massive headache for parents". But if such babysitting is so crucial to a functioning society, surely society can become a bit less rigid to accommodate it?
- mbg721 5y agoThe people who really dislike the state don't use the state's schools anyway; this is more like "The post office, the courts, and the banks have done this for decades," so other businesses and individuals also find it convenient to use the same time conventions.
- jameshart 5y agoPrivate schools also have start times. Not sure what your argument is.
- hannasanarion 5y agoYeah, and they can decide for themselves what their start times are. We don't need 300 millon people to experience jet lag twice a year to save some bougy superintendent the inconvenience of scribbling out a number and writing a different one one time.
- paul_f 5y agoBabybsitters? You might want to sit this one out.
- floucky 5y agoYou could force schools and daycare to open and close early. Also do this with public companies. Offer a tax discount on the first hour for companies. I'm sure we can find other solutions.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- drawkbox 5y agoAnother faction would be the developers that have to deal with the time changing. Would just be easier to change at a personal level than changing time itself. Arizona doesn't do alot right but no DST is one big one they do. Times of work/events/appts/etc change, not time itself.
- zaat 5y agoI think you misspelled sysadmins there. My experience is that, at least in the traditional corporate world, it is the DBAs who connect just before midnight to put their precious SQL servers to sleep during the danger time, since who know how the software will behave in the real world. In some places DST dates are often changed in the last minute, wrecking havoc everyone's calendar meetings and inflicting pain on the Exchange servers admins.
- eru 5y agoThat seems a bit silly to me? That's a problem that occurs every years twice; so we should write code to automate it instead of dealing with it by admin hands.
- RajT88 5y agoThe problem is we have to keep updating that code when the rules change. Servers which miss that patch break because of various Auth schemes which require clocks to be reasonably in sync between machines. So you get a bunch of outages whenever the next time shift is post-rules change. I am less annoyed with DST than I am at how often we are fucking with it and breaking stuff.
- fphhotchips 5y agoI like it when the US fucks with time zones. The more you fuck with time zones, the more likely US-based developers are to just say fuck it, we'll use a library. The more developers that use a library for time zones, the fewer pieces of software that I have to deal with that get this wrong for my part of the world. (Did you know Australia has 11 possible time zones of which up to 9 are being used right now? It might even be 12. Most people don't, which is why most programmers fuck it up)
- imoverclocked 5y ago... and another sub-faction that thinks time-zones are also a horrible idea.
- colejohnson66 5y agoYou’re never gonna convince the world to remove time zones. Switch to UTC and now the idea of the sun rising between 5-7 AMish is ruined because it would be 2 AM where I am now. Since the invention of the sundial, time zones have existed in some form or another. Programmers just have deal with it.
- eru 5y agoThe sun doesn't rise between 5-7 AM-ish in many parts of the world. First, if you timezone is 'right', on average the sun should rise about 6 am. In winter, it rises later, in summer it rises earlier. Where I grew up in Germany the sun rose as late as 8:20 am in winter. And funny enough, the latest rise in Madrid in Spain is at 8:40 am in winter. That's because Madrid is on the 'wrong' timezone: it's in the same timezone as Germany, but much further west. (You are right however, that time zones do roughly keep noon around 12-ish. It's just that the band of variation around the world is quite a lot wider than you might imagine.)
- mcronce 5y ago> Switch to UTC and now the idea of the sun rising between 5-7 AMish is ruined And this idea is critically important because?
- colejohnson66 5y agoIt alone isn’t. But the notion of the sun rising in the mid-AM, midday being at noon, and the sun then setting in the mid-PM is literally as old as the sundial. There’s no way you’re convincing society that “no timezones” is a good thing.
- myrryr 5y agoRight, UTC all of the things!
- tshaddox 5y ago> People who believe that it should be possible for a society to agree on things just starting an hour earlier (or later) where it makes sense, all without literally touching a single clock. To be fair, isn’t that essentially what DST systems are? Literally the way that a society arranges to have everything start an hour earlier or later at different times of year is to designate dates where everyone sets their clocks back or forward an hour. Granted, it doesn’t fulfill your “all without literally touching a single clock” requirement, because a few types of common clocks still require manual adjustment, but the complaints about DST aren’t about the hassle of literally adjusting the clock on your microwave, right? The complaints are about the sudden disruptions to one’s schedule, especially the amount of sleep one gets on two specific nights every year—and your proposal doesn’t solve that problem. And if we instead agreed to change, for instance, the operating hours of every business twice a year, surely the physical changing of signage would be similarly costly.
- lxgr 5y ago> To be fair, isn’t that essentially what DST systems are? Not exactly: DST solves for not having to have seasonal/variable schedules. Without DST, we lose that, and we do actually get to decide, once, how we want to arrange our lives in this new, linear time – implicitly or explicitly.
- bhaak 5y agoFor public transport (at least here in Europe), we do already have variable schedules anyway. As students often use public transport to go to school, schedules often have reduced service during school holidays.
- hahajk 5y agoFunny enough, for jobs that do schedule around sunrise/sunset (like flying), DST is even more disruptive. Perhaps you used to get a sandwich after your day flight but when DST starts, everything suddenly closes an hour earlier!
- Thorrez 5y ago
- eru 5y agoAt least the permanent offset can be worked around easier than the silly DST switching all the time. For all I care, the US could get itself on UTC, if they don't care too much about their clocks being in sync with the sun anyway.
- incompatible 5y agoThat would be kind of convenient, but also a bit confusing if you travelled and found the clocks reading a different time than you expected for a particular time of day. The general convention is to have local noon at roughly 12:00, although then you have to deal with zones.
- eru 5y agoYes. I'm not actually advocating for putting everyone on UTC.
- kerryoco 5y ago"if they don't care too much about their clocks being in sync with the sun" this is pretty important though. We need both absolute and relative time unfortunately, as a consequence of this messy physically embodied universe we find ourselves in. I too yearned for One Time Scale to Rule Them All, to no avail.
- IgorPartola 5y agoWhy? If you know you wake up at 3am to get to work at 4am and get out of work at noon, then go to sleep at 7pm and you do this every single day then who cares that it doesn’t line up with some magical other numbers?
- lxgr 5y agoThe notion of days (as today, tomorrow and yesterday) does not really make sense without time zones.
- xattt 5y agoI worked in an mission-critical environment with a traditional 12-hour schedule where the option for this flexibility wasn’t mandated. Staff dreaded working the fall-back shift because they ended up working an extra hour for free. The union brought this up at every round of negotiations, but were told to pound sand by the employer and asked what they would like to give up instead.