4 ms·
But the article's author would probably regard "why would someone use your engine over Google" as a reasonably good question, as opposed to "nobody is going to
by kazinator 5y ago
But the article's author would probably regard "why would someone use your engine over Google" as a reasonably good question, as opposed to "nobody is going to use your engine over Google because it's a household verb".
It's not the same as the author's example "what makes you believe you can do better than Google" because that question assumes you are doing exactly the same thing as Google: that all the prospective users of the idea are fully satisfied with Google, and have to be convinced to use something else for no reason at all. Your "why would someone use your search engine over Google" is better; it's more closely in line with "how will you get your first users".
- randrews 5y ago> "why would someone use your engine over Google" as a reasonably good question, as opposed to "nobody is going to use your engine over Google because it's a household verb". Well, one of these is a question, the other is a statement... Actually I noticed that if you look at his examples of what not to say, none of them are questions. So maybe a better idea is "don't say discouraging things to your founder friends, ask them questions instead."
- kazinator 5y agoThose statements are not grammatically questions, but they are questioning statements. You can easily turn them into rhetorical questions: "LOL, do you really think someone is going to use your search engine over Google?"
- LordDragonfang 5y agoGP picked that example because the article explicitly calls it a bad question. The third paragraph of the article: >Let’s say your friend is obsessed with building a new search-engine. When you ask them why do they believe they can do better than Google, you are literally telling them that they shouldn’t be doing this since if it was ‘correct’ or possible or profitable, then Google would have already done that. This is bad.
- kazinator 5y agoIt's not the same at all, because that question insinuates that Google is already doing everything close to as best as possible. Whereas users who use Google may have reasons to use an alternative engine even if it isn't strictly better than Google in every regard. Probing into who those users might be and what their needs are envisioned to be is more constructive than "can you do better than Google"?