4 ms·
First things first: I don't think there's anything wrong with the design based on the screenshots. At least, nothing stands out as being so unusable that users
by rchaud 5y ago
First things first: I don't think there's anything wrong with the design based on the screenshots. At least, nothing stands out as being so unusable that users would flee for your competitor.
As for "Gen Z preferences", I don't think there's enough to go on here to prove that. I'm over 35 and have watched user interfaces go from the the fun, colourful and UNIQUE designs of the 2009-era iOS apps to the hyper-corporate, boring af grid system that's "Apple Approved". Android is similar, w/ Material Design. I think they have a new one now that replaces MD, but I can't be bothered to look it up.
You're creating a video speed dating app. Dating is supposed to be FUN. Why design it like Zoom? Have you used trivia apps like QuizUp? You'll notice how different the design and dynamics are compared to most apps that are designed to render text/image data in specified fields.
Also look at TikTok/Douyin for an example of unconventional app design. They could have just copied Instagram, which is blandness personified. But they went with an unfamilar style that nonetheless took off. Nobody's asking "how do I turn my camera on" there, are they?
- JPKab 5y agoReally on point here. Having worked at a company where our VCs demanded we "do what Google does" and then had to adopt the entire "design system" approach, it ends up robbing UIs of anything fun, because all UIs become "design by committee" by default.
- mwcampbell 5y agoThis doesn't apply to all types of applications, but one person's fun may prevent another person from completing a task or even having a particular job. Yes, it's possible to design UIs that are both fun (whatever that means) and accessible. But it seems to me that boring, by-the-book UIs are more likely to be accessible by default.
- ravenstine 5y ago> I think they have a new one now that replaces MD, but I can't be bothered to look it up. Do you mean Material Design 3, or something else? https://m3.material.io/ https://m3.material.io/
- perardi 5y agoFor Android, you’re talking about Material You, which is a bit more colorful and bubbly. https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/11/android-12-the-ars-technica-review/#h1 https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2021/11/android-12-the-ars-t... — And as to grid systems…well, that isn’t exactly a recent development. Design and typography has been dealing and fighting about grid systems for a long, long time now. This is not a new discussion. At all. We just generally don’t think a lot about the full history of design. https://www.moma.org/calendar/exhibitions/1013 https://www.moma.org/calendar/exhibitions/1013
- causi 5y agoEvery time they update Android it puts less information on the screen. Android 20 is going to have the same UI as an Apple Watch.
- mortenjorck 5y agoBeyond a few distinguishing elements, the design of the author's app and the design of the purported Gen-Z app aren't really all that far apart. At the basic level, both are built on a contemporary, minimalist UI discipline, with a similar approach to visually differentiating elements like buttons and fields. The later mostly distinguishes itself typographically, adopting a very trendy "brutalist" type family, with associated practices like mixing widths in the same line. The only other differences are more saturated, high-contrast colors and ambient animation. The end result for the latter may be considerably less minimalist, but the foundations have a lot more in common than they have differences.
- jkaptur 5y agoIt's funny that you bring up grid systems, because the screenshot of the partiful really evokes how some designers have played with grid systems in decidedly non-minimalist ways: e.g. https://vanle.info/blog/2021/february/josef-muller-brockmann-posters.php https://vanle.info/blog/2021/february/josef-muller-brockmann...
- blihp 5y agoWhat's old is new again. It's not a generational thing, it's a market maturity thing. There were plenty of unique UI's in the 80's (every OS with a GUI had a distinct look and feel) and 90's (most OS GUIs had started to look and feel like Windows but a few daring applications took a chance to be different). Kai's Power Tools[1] was my favorite as it had a distinctive look and feel but was entirely functional. There were a number Mac apps with carefully crafted and unique UI's in the pre-iOS days which no doubt took a ton of effort vs. just making a bland Windows-esque UI. It's not so much that developers stop wanting to push the envelope, it's that beyond being an early stage differentiation gimmick, users don't tend to reward them for very long for the effort. So developers focus on what they do get rewarded for which tend to be the checkbox features vs. their competition and the UI is demoted to whatever the lowest-effort fashion of the day is. Even Apple seems to have settled on slapping on a fresh coat of paint every few years and calling it a day. [1] https://macintoshgarden.org/apps/kais-power-tools-30 https://macintoshgarden.org/apps/kais-power-tools-30
- bsder 5y agoThe problem with ALL of these stupid mobile designs is always twofold: 1) The important information is rarely the obvious thing on the page. Partiful! Yay, party! Where? When? Cost? Oh, that grey on grey blob. Even filteroff, WTF am I searching for? Why does your "Ready for date night" take up 1/3 of the damn screen instead of something useful to me? 2) Interactable objects aren't obvious. Presumable that stupid double circle is a trendy hamburger menu. Oh, wait, no, I've get a hamburger down and right. Whats scrolls? What clicks? And how do I go back. As a side bonus, these types of Social Crapware apps (dating, party, etc.) have a special failure mode: 3) Design for these kinds of apps is ALL about attracting to your app lots of the cruise director type--generally a female who is nominally single and probably right in her mid-20s (age isn't as critical as female and nominally single). Consequently, design for 25-year-old Anya supersedes ANYTHING else. Period. Bar none. What Anya thinks is good IS good and overrides any other consideration. Follow that trend or get kicked to the curb by the company who does.
- sizzle 5y agoYou outlined some powerful behavioral and social aspects I have not seen written in any design guidelines or design system anywhere to date. Thanks for expanding my thinking on the dating app Anya design dilemma hah