4 ms·
It's worse than he says. Not only do EV have stunning acceleration which grandpa will most likely not be able to control, they're extremely heavy, especially at
by oblio 5y ago
It's worse than he says. Not only do EV have stunning acceleration which grandpa will most likely not be able to control, they're extremely heavy, especially at the bottom end.
From what I've read a VW Golf weighs between 1300 - 1600kg. A VW ID.3, practically the same car but electric, weighs between 1800 - 1900kg. That's a small car weighing as much as a bigger, older ICE SUV. An almost 40% weight increase over the equivalent ICE. Battery weight will really need to go down.
Plus we're going to have to really upgrade road infrastructure to make it safer.
- speedgoose 5y agoA BMW i3 is lighter than a VW Golf. A Dacia spring is even lighter, and extremely slow.
- JaimeThompson 5y agoDacia? Good news!
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoThe i3 is built out of carbon fibre, that was never going to be viable for a mainstream car like the Golf. The Dacia Spring is comparable to the VW Up which is two tiers down from the Golf.
- saiya-jin 5y agoThey don't need to have so many HP, I can imagine battery would last much longer in city environment / slow traffic if cars accelerated like their ICE counterparts, with extra safety as a nice bonus. But marketing sells and people act on emotions. So people who got into electric cars suddenly drive harder, creating more pollution ie from tyres and brake discs (that added weight makes this also much worse). It ain't fun for lungs and overall health to breath in metallic or burned rubber nanoparticles. It looks like we will change visible pollution in the cities for less visible, but at least as deadly one.
- mark-r 5y agoElectric cars can use regenerative braking, so they're much easier on the brake pads - the electric motors might handle 90% of the braking force. I have to laugh every time I take my hybrid in for service and they say "the brake pads are fine".
- saiya-jin 5y agoThat's a good point, thank you
- pmoriarty 5y ago"EV have stunning acceleration which grandpa will most likely not be able to control..." Shouldn't it be possible to model the EV's acceleration on a combustion engine car, and/or let the driver select the type of acceleration they want?
- lbriner 5y agoOf course you could change its torque curve, and people will complain about the nanny state. As with everything, you're damned if you do and damned if you don't.
- stonogo 5y agoMild ties to right-to-repair here, but it seems like the 'old' car market had this figured out. Ship a sane power curve by default, and the aftermarket can handle tuning, which makes it a deliberate choice by the owner. Or, tune the hell out of the power curve and sell it as a muscle car. Either way, there's plenty of space between "prohibit fun" and "default mild."
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoMost of them do have a selection of profiles so you can choose economy or sport modes. In reality I bet most are going to be stuck in economy because despite the enormous expense they are still poor on range.
- mikestew 5y agoEven in our first-ten Leaf we generally leave it in economy mode. That mode is fast enough, and frankly even in that underpowered Leaf (110bhp/250ft-lbs, IIRC?) regular mode is a little too torquey for most driving. That's not to say that if I need to get across that intersection before you do that I won't slip out of economy mode and enjoy the ride.
- thesimon 5y agoWhy not compare the VW Golf to the eGolf? Weighs 1615kg https://ev-database.org/car/1087/Volkswagen-e-Golf https://ev-database.org/car/1087/Volkswagen-e-Golf
- tonyedgecombe 5y agoPresumably because the e-golf is discontinued and the ID.3 is more representative of the future of EV's.
- eptcyka 5y agoThe rate of acceleration is limited by the tire, and EVs usually have low rolling resistance tires. And those same EVs also have traction control that's calibrated for these same tires. The end result is that the EVs are just as controllable as regular ICE cars. I'd argue that due to the linear power delivery, they are more predictable, unlike some ICE cars. If a human is incapable of operating an EV, they wouldn't be capable of operating an ICE car either, and as such they shouldn't be in possession of a drivers license.
- oblio 5y ago> If a human is incapable of operating an EV, they wouldn't be capable of operating an ICE car either, and as such they shouldn't be in possession of a drivers license. Have you seen those discussions about American drivers where driving is basically a human right after 16 years since most Americans live in places with no or bad public transport? I don't even know if they test old drivers regularly in the US.
- masklinn 5y ago> Not only do EV have stunning acceleration which grandpa will most likely not be able to control That's a profile choice, it's not like you have to do this since it's all drive by wire. For instance the folks from lightyear one were not interested in acceleration, the car is specced for 0-100 in "less than 10 seconds" and that's about it. That's for a 150k car too. Plus the Mach-E's acceleration... is in line with regular mustangs: the normal versions are 5 to 6s, only the GT is 3.8 (or even 3.5 for the GT-PE). The 2020 Mustangs range from 5.1s for the EcoBoost to 3.7 for the GT500.
- rad_gruchalski 5y agoThey're also loud inside, in my experience louder than ICE vehicles. i3 at 130kph+ doesn't allow for normal conversation, especially when it's raining. It's very difficult to know how fast the car is going without constantly observing the speedometer, I dread any EV without a HUD. The acceleration is very uncomfortable to some of my passengers because of the instant torque and lack of noise feedback. I very much do not like one pedal driving. Second leg is hanging there doing nothing. The need to constantly keep the acceleration pedal pressed is annoying, slight repositioning of the foot makes the car lose speed in an instant. I do not like that there is no center tunnel. In an ICE vehicle, when the foot is on the accelerator, the knee rests on the tunnel and is supported by the tunnel. In an EV, because of that space, the leg doesn't have anything to rest on. This is very annoying on long distances.
- UncleOxidant 5y agoThis doesn't make sense. Electric motors are a good bit quieter than gas engines - in fact some manufacturers are adding noise-makers so that pedestrians can hear them coming. You say "especially when raining" which makes me think that this is an issue with the noise dampening of the particular vehicle you're talking about.
- rad_gruchalski 5y agoYeah, I mean inside, They're louder inside. I don't know if this is maybe related to the compensation in weight where some of the noise cancelling padding is removed to save weight because batteries are heavy enough already.
- colinmhayes 5y agoAbsolutely not my experience with EVs. They are much quieter at all speeds.
- rad_gruchalski 5y agoIf "at any speed" is up to 60 or 70kph, yeah. Going 130kph+ is unbearable.
- sbradford26 5y agoI won't deny that EVs are heavier, but you are comparing two completely different vehicles. A better comparison would be comparing the 2019 Golf (1371 Kg) to the 2019 e-Golf (1567 Kg). Also the lower center of mass is advantage in some aspects since it significantly reduces rollover risk. Volkswagen Golf Dimensions 2020: Height 1452mm Width 1799mm Length 4258mm Volkswagen ID.4 Dimensions 2022: Height 1651mm Width 1854mm Length 4597mm
- oblio 5y agoI said ID.3, not ID.4. Your comment missed that :-)
- UncleOxidant 5y ago> Battery weight will really need to go down. And/or the cars could be much smaller and more efficient like the Aptera [1] which uses about 1/2 as much energy/mile (100Wh/mile) than a Tesla does (220 Wh/mile). Much of that is due to being more aerodynamic, but also due to being lighter. Which means you don't have to carry as much battery weight around to get the same range. [1] https://aptera.us/ https://aptera.us/
- oblio 5y agoTheir vehicle might be light but their website froze my desktop Firefox... On a more serious note, that's a 2 seater with a small trunk, from what I see. Good luck getting mass adoption for it. Plus it looks more like a prototype, and we've seen thousands of those. By the time it gets into production it will need to add extra safety and comfort features which will add weight.
- UncleOxidant 5y agoYep, it's a two seater. For a lot of us a two-seater is all we need for like 99.9% of all of our trips. Also, you can get a surprising amount of groceries into that thing. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YWukO5TLssM&t=14s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YWukO5TLssM&t=14s
- oblio 5y agoWell, I wish them luck. Unfortunately, there's also another factor, and people are sensitive to this stuff. To me, it looks ugly. Plus, I'm obviously thinking: if their form factor is so revolutionary, why has nobody used it? Though technically we had similar looking stuff, wheel arches were super popular during the 30s. What did they discover that literally every other major car maker didn't? That form factor went away for a (presumably solid) reason.
- UncleOxidant 5y ago> To me, it looks ugly In the eye of the beholder. I think it looks like a space car from the future.