4 ms·
I've never seen a take on this that seemed plausible and logical. I thought I was going to be pleasantly surprised by this one as it got very technical at the s
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
I've never seen a take on this that seemed plausible and logical. I thought I was going to be pleasantly surprised by this one as it got very technical at the start but it kind of went weird at the end.
So, for oil they think the sanctions will remain and Asia can only take so much and will do so at a discount. At some point Russia will run out of storage and have to stop producing.
This feels like bad news for Russia. Though later on they claim Russia can cut off gas because it's only 6%, but we just covered how 30% of their revenue is about to hit a wall. Can they survive another 6% cut on top of that? Plus increased retaliatory sanctions? While continuing an expensive, unpopular and unsuccessful war?
For gas, they specifically say that there's not enough gas to fill current demand AND fill the storage tanks to a EU mandated 90%.
Let's assume that's true. Does EU need the storage tanks to be 90% full or is that a nice to have? If other countries are making a concerted effort to lower their storage to ease price spikes, then it seems likely the EU could too.
So, how much damage can Russia actually do by cutting off gas, how much does that damage Russia and what's the chance of that happening? Why does this article not even try to ask or answer that question?
Is there anything that can't be solved by printing money and/or windfall taxing it back from people who profit from this situation and using it to electrify? If not why not? If so, then why aren't we doing that?
And why is this generally seen as so impossible it's not worth considering? The whole world has a 25 year plan to phase this stuff out so it seems a bit odd that cutting down a bit at short notice is seen as such a complete non-starter. "Heat pumps for peace" seems like a very logical plan for American manufacturing, so why is it not being put into practice?
Maybe it's the control that our own fossil oligarchs have on our politics which is the big weakness here, if we're not even able to talk about solutions which might inconvenience them, but save us money but we are keen to scaremonger their profits.