4 ms·
> a particularly abstract, intellectual thing that people who (appear to be) much smarter than me seem to understand but which I cannot. It’s not a “smarts” th
by gumby 5y ago
> a particularly abstract, intellectual thing that people who (appear to be) much smarter than me seem to understand but which I cannot.
It’s not a “smarts” thing, but it is highly contextual.
European philosophy went in an interesting (and often derided) direction in the 20th century. You can trace a line from 13th century scholars of hermeneutics up through Heidegger and Wittgenstein— smart folks! — and then, in the US, to people like Quine.
In Europe this also lead to approaches like deconstructionism (let me gloss it as “wait, can a text exist without context?”, which is almost the precise opposite of those hermeneuticists of 900 years ago). These classes of questions were then applied to everyday culture and phenomena, which were often not the subject of study, e.g. thus semiotics. This is actually a really interesting field, because it causes you to revisit things that are so ubiquitous that you don’t look at them at all! For example, “land”, is generally the space between the roads, yet roads used to run through the land. Big deal…or not? Are there implications of this shift in perspective or is it merely just one of those things?
Of course the problem is it’s really easy to do a lazy job on these hard but not really quantifiable questions and thus it became the darling of a lot of humanities departments, leading to a kind of Gresham’s law phenomenon. The flood of fatuous and obscurantist work has condemned the whole field to well deserved mockery.
But a bit of study can unlock a lot of interesting insight. I say “a bit of study” because easily 95% of the “work” in this field is crap. And at the end of the day it’s nowhere near as hard (or significant) as, say, quantum mechanics.