4 ms·
It's not about roots. Especially now, there's a risk the Fed may raise interest rates to counter inflation which could negatively impact asset prices. And mort
by AnthonyMouse 5y ago
It's not about roots. Especially now, there's a risk the Fed may raise interest rates to counter inflation which could negatively impact asset prices.
And mortgaging a house is leverage.
If you put your money in stocks and they go down 15%, you lose 15% of your money. If you plonk a 15% downpayment on a house and the house loses 15% of its value, you get zeroed out.
No guarantee that happens right now, but it sure could.
- seibelj 5y agoI have a lot of investments but my property has been both a winner and something accessible to even non-wealthy people because of the socialized costs. Highly recommend property to everyone.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoIn general the "people are born short a house" thing is true. Buying a house at some point in your life is a good idea. At this moment we're in a housing bubble inflated by low interest rates that may or may not be about to end. The risk is different than it usually is.
- seibelj 5y agoShelter is something you need. If you rent, the cost rises with inflation. With the US government, taxpayers effectively pay the inflation for you. The laws of the USA subsidize your property to make it artificially cheaper. I can’t imagine a better deal for someone with enough money for a down payment.
- AnthonyMouse 5y agoThe US subsidizes it and then artificially constrains the housing supply through zoning, so the subsidies just inflate the purchase price and go to the banks as interest on higher principal or to the people who owned property when the subsidies were first implemented. The ROI is attributable to the supply constraint in the face of population growth, not the subsidies. If housing supply wasn't constrained the subsidies would lower the initial cost but then it wouldn't work as an investment because the real value would never go up since if it did that would cause an increase in supply through new construction. But that's also what makes it a pyramid scheme. More people bidding on the same amount of housing makes the price go up, but only if the population grows. Fertility rate tells a bad story there. And on top of that it's per-city; ask people who had homes in Detroit. Someday this is all going to fall apart. I don't know when it's going to be though.
- piva00 5y agoTragedy of the commons, when you got into this game your participation in it made it much worse to everyone else: prospect house buyers, taxpayers and so on. Not a judgment of your character or anything, it makes rational financial sense as an individual to participate in it but if everyone followed your path we'd be thoroughly fucked with housing prices. More than what it already is.
- rocqua 5y agoIf you put 15% down and the house value drops, you still save on rent. Paying down a mortgage is paying back a loan. Paying rent is just paying someone.
- refurb 5y agoNope. I lucked out in 2007 and decided to rent rather than buy. Economy went into the shitter after and after a couple years my company had lay offs but I was lucky enough to jump to a better role in another city. I spent $36,000 in rent over 2 years. I had several friends who bought with $60,000 down and paid $50,000 in mortgage payments and property taxes. When I moved I gave my landlord the keys and got my deposit back. When they moved their house was way underwater, so they sent the bank the keys and walked away. I spent $74,000+ less on housing than they did by renting. It was just luck and sure an extreme example but man the lessons of 2008 have been very quickly forgotten.
- geoduck14 5y ago>It was just luck and sure an extreme example but man the lessons of 2008 have been very quickly forgotten. You're right, but I'd like to share with you a lesson I learned in 2020/2021. Every single leader that has been around since 2008 is terrified of "mortgage" causing 2 recessions in a row. Seeing people rally around house prices and evections over the past two years really solidified this for me.