3 ms·
>This too is incorrect. The US has not asked Ukraine to 'join NATO', it has been the other way around. Russia has been told in no uncertain terms that it isn't
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
>This too is incorrect. The US has not asked Ukraine to 'join NATO', it has been the other way around. Russia has been told in no uncertain terms that it isn't up to them whether or not Ukraine joins NATO, but that this is up to NATO (and it's various partners).
Yes, Ukraine applied. The US and other NATO nations can decide if they are considered or not. The US and other NATO nations can decide if they are accepted or not. Ukraine can apply or not apply, but beyond this the US and NATO have all the power to decide the outcome. When Ukraine did apply in ~2008, many NATO countries including Germany and France did not want to expand east as it would provoke Russia and increase the risk of war in Europe. Using it's formidable leverage, the US convinced NATO to entertain Ukraine's application.
The US and other NATO countries still have the power to change policy with respect to Ukraine, and state that it will never be granted membership. The US could unilaterally do this today if they wished Ukraine to have a neutral status.
The parent article askes what the west can offer to bring peace and obtain a Russian withdrawal. This is certainly one such option that is technically possible (if unpopular).
From the US perspective, regime change in Russia is attractive, but every day that goes by Ukrainians die.
- jacquesm 5y agoOnce again: the West doesn't have anything that it can give Russia to withdraw, Russia needs a victory in Ukraine of some sort before it will withdraw. This has been the historical problem with any kind of incursion from Russia into some other country, if it did not work out to Russia's advantage the leadership there tended to change. The victory that the West can give Russia would be to starve Ukraine from aid - financial, arms - and the opposite of that is happening, though in time it may come to that. The US does not control who goes into NATO other than that they can say 'no' (like everybody else). This is no longer just a war of arms, it is a war of clocks: Putin's time is running out and Ukraine's time is running out, the question who has the longer time on their clock and that will likely determine the outcome. The West has just drastically shortened the time on Putin's clock while at the same time extending the Ukrainian clock substantially. To reverse that trend so that Russia can have its win seems unlikely and any other token wins (such as Ukraine 'never' joining NATO, which by itself is a pretty dumb thing to ask for as a settlement because that wasn't happening anyway, and besides that's none of Russia's business) are going to be insufficient to explain to the rest of the Russians why they will likely go hungry for the next couple of years and why they won't be able to go abroad. Make no mistake: Russia has made itself into a Pariah state and it will take more than some token concession to get back to 'normal'.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoYou are arguing an opinion independent of what I am saying. >West doesn't have anything that it can give Russia to withdraw The west absolutely does have something it can give Russia, This is indisputable. One can argue over if this would be enough to secure withdrawal or not. One can argue if it is wise to give something to Russia. > The US does not control who goes into NATO other than that they can say 'no' (like everybody else). Correct, Saying "no" is control and this is something that the US can promise to Russia. Russia asked the US several times for this explicitly before the war, threatening to invade if they didn't get it. >This is no longer just a war of arms, it is a war of clocks: This may be entirely true, I am not arguing that it isn't the case. This is independent of the question of if the US and west can give concessions. >any other token wins (such as Ukraine 'never' joining NATO, which by itself is a pretty dumb thing to ask for as a settlement because that wasn't happening anyway This is not factually true. In 2021 NATO declared verbatim that Ukraine would become part of NATO and its process would proceed. People can debate of if this was wise or not. Obviously Russia does does not get a vote on NATO decisions, and I'm not saying that it does. This does not negate the fact that in the real world, Russia has very strong opinions on it. A maniac with a gun doesn't have a legal right to shoot someone, but that does not mean that they cant do it! >Make no mistake: Russia has made itself into a Pariah state and it will take more than some token concession to get back to 'normal'. I never said otherwise.
- gamechangr 5y agoUnfortunately that's not exactly how it works. All member nations have to agree to unanimously vote in new countries. Both Germany and France have historically blocked Ukraines attempt to join. Presumably, German and France are slow to add conflict with Russia due to their dependence on Russia's Gas Exports. Here is an article I think is insightful to some of the process to joining NATO: hit the link: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30677251 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30677251
- s1artibartfast 5y agoThe article matches what I'm saying exactly regarding the application process and need for unanimous consent. One nation can sink the whole process. Moreover, the US could agree to not arm and train Ukraine even outside of the NATO application process. What it leaves out is that in 2021 NATO reaffirmed that “Ukraine will become a member of the Alliance with the Membership Action Plan (MAP)", which is the most traction on the topic since 2008.[1] The idea that Biden has grown skeptical of expanding U.S. military commitments is farcical in this context. At the same time leading up to the war, the US was providing more military aid and training to Ukraine than ever. https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/news_185000.htm https://www.nato.int/cps/en/natohq/news_185000.htm >Both Germany and France have historically blocked Ukraines attempt to join. This is not factually true. Joining NATO is a multi step process. No Vote has ever been held on Ukraine joining. Several votes have been held on if Ukraine can progress closer to being a member. In each case Germany and France initially blocked the step, and then later accepted under pressure from the US. The first was in 2008 when NATO decided if Ukraine could start the process. In 2016, Ukraine was granted a NATO Comprehensive Assistance Package (CAP), comprising the advisory mission at the NATO Representation to Ukraine as well as 16 capacity-building programmes and Trust Funds. In 2018, Ukraine was officially given an aspiring member status. 2021 NATO reaffirmed that Ukraine will become a member. In each step, unanimous consent was achieved after initial protest from NATO members. Full membership was probably decades out, but starting around 2014, the US was gifting significant arms to Ukraine, stationing troops in the country, and training their military.