3 ms·
I strongly disagree. The US and Russia have all the agency here. Ukraine is indeed a sovereign nation, but the US has full control of the arms flowing in, its
by s1artibartfast 5y ago
I strongly disagree. The US and Russia have all the agency here.
Ukraine is indeed a sovereign nation, but the US has full control of the arms flowing in, its ability to fight, and Ukraines NATO aspirations.
The US has the power to decide if Ukraine stands or falls. The US also has the power to to give Russia some or all of what it wants. Ukraine has very little say.
- jacquesm 5y ago> the US has full control of the arms flowing in This is incorrect. > its ability to fight This is incorrect > Ukraines NATO aspirations This is irrelevant. > The US has the power to decide if Ukraine stands or falls The US has the power to decide if it wants to help Ukraine beyond what it has already done, and it has the power to decide if it wants to stop giving the help that it is giving right now. But it does not have the power to decide whether Ukraine stands or falls, that power lies first and foremost - unfortunately - with Russia and after that with Ukraine itself. > The US also has the power to to give Russia some or all of what it wants. No, it doesn't have that power at all. > Ukraine has very little say. That may be so but you have a pretty weird idea of how war works, and you seem to forget that Europe has a fairly large amount of influence in the region as well.
- s1artibartfast 5y ago>> Ukraines NATO aspirations >This is irrelevant. >>The US also has the power to to give Russia some or all of what it wants. >No, it doesn't have that power at all. This is literally one of Russias demands, which the US has the power to unilaterally grant or deny. US arms, money, and support are necessary if Ukraine has any chance of long term success. NATO will always fall in line with US demands.
- jacquesm 5y ago> This is literally one of Russias demands, which the US has the power to unilaterally grant or deny. Again, incorrect. Why do you keep saying stuff that is factually incorrect? > US arms, money, and support are necessary if Ukraine has any chance of long term success. They would certainly help, but they are not the only kind of support that Ukraine is receiving. > NATO will always fall in line with US demands. This too is incorrect. The US has not asked Ukraine to 'join NATO', it has been the other way around. Russia has been told in no uncertain terms that it isn't up to them whether or not Ukraine joins NATO, but that this is up to NATO (and it's various partners). The US is obviously a formidable player in international politics and in many ways and on many fronts it is the only player. And currently several partners in NATO have wildly different viewpoints on how to deal best with the war in Ukraine, but one thing they all seem to agree on is simply that as long as the war is limited to Ukrainian territory that they will not intervene directly. That said, NATO, and in particular Poland is already involved in quite a few ways and their decisions have a very large effect on the outcome. This stopped being about Ukraine vs Russia a while ago, the question that matters is whether or not it will spiral out of control and pull the rest of the Eastern European countries into it and how if that happens NATO will respond. And for all of the statements that have been made the proof of the pudding will be in the eating. Personally I hope that Ukraine with continued assistance from Europe and the US will hold out long enough that someone with a bit more sense will seize power in Russia, which is the best possible outcome. Failing that you may get to a point where you regret living in this particular decade. Who does or does not join NATO is utterly irrelevant compared to the stakes, and Russia can demand all it wants, as long as it does not withdraw (or at least declares a ceasefire) from Ukraine the crisis is deepening by the day.
- s1artibartfast 5y ago>This too is incorrect. The US has not asked Ukraine to 'join NATO', it has been the other way around. Russia has been told in no uncertain terms that it isn't up to them whether or not Ukraine joins NATO, but that this is up to NATO (and it's various partners). Yes, Ukraine applied. The US and other NATO nations can decide if they are considered or not. The US and other NATO nations can decide if they are accepted or not. Ukraine can apply or not apply, but beyond this the US and NATO have all the power to decide the outcome. When Ukraine did apply in ~2008, many NATO countries including Germany and France did not want to expand east as it would provoke Russia and increase the risk of war in Europe. Using it's formidable leverage, the US convinced NATO to entertain Ukraine's application. The US and other NATO countries still have the power to change policy with respect to Ukraine, and state that it will never be granted membership. The US could unilaterally do this today if they wished Ukraine to have a neutral status. The parent article askes what the west can offer to bring peace and obtain a Russian withdrawal. This is certainly one such option that is technically possible (if unpopular). From the US perspective, regime change in Russia is attractive, but every day that goes by Ukrainians die.
- jacquesm 5y agoOnce again: the West doesn't have anything that it can give Russia to withdraw, Russia needs a victory in Ukraine of some sort before it will withdraw. This has been the historical problem with any kind of incursion from Russia into some other country, if it did not work out to Russia's advantage the leadership there tended to change. The victory that the West can give Russia would be to starve Ukraine from aid - financial, arms - and the opposite of that is happening, though in time it may come to that. The US does not control who goes into NATO other than that they can say 'no' (like everybody else). This is no longer just a war of arms, it is a war of clocks: Putin's time is running out and Ukraine's time is running out, the question who has the longer time on their clock and that will likely determine the outcome. The West has just drastically shortened the time on Putin's clock while at the same time extending the Ukrainian clock substantially. To reverse that trend so that Russia can have its win seems unlikely and any other token wins (such as Ukraine 'never' joining NATO, which by itself is a pretty dumb thing to ask for as a settlement because that wasn't happening anyway, and besides that's none of Russia's business) are going to be insufficient to explain to the rest of the Russians why they will likely go hungry for the next couple of years and why they won't be able to go abroad. Make no mistake: Russia has made itself into a Pariah state and it will take more than some token concession to get back to 'normal'.