4 ms·
We can fly ultralights without a license. Granted those "vehicles" technically aren't airplanes and generally only result in loss of life to one's self. "We do
by giantg2 5y ago
We can fly ultralights without a license. Granted those "vehicles" technically aren't airplanes and generally only result in loss of life to one's self.
"We don't have even the political willpower to take away licenses from obviously unfit seniors"
I believe many states do require a retest after a certain age.
"or making the tests hard enough that way fewer people can get one in the first place"
Fewer, sure. Way fewer, maybe not. I think most people are capable of safely operating a car. I think there would be a large percentage that would just need to put more effort into learning. The way it is now is that people remain ignorant on the subject because they aren't required to study and learn, because licenses are practically given away. Plus, why waste time learning the law if nobody else follows it either?
Tougher licensing isn't (or shouldn't be) primarily about depriving people of licenses, but rather providing forced incentives to learn through testing standards. The standards shouldn't be so high as to prevent most people from driving. If they are then we could change some of the rules or designs to simplify the process, although likely at the expense of rate of flow.
- mikepurvis 5y ago> providing forced incentives to learn through testing standards Fair, yes. I think I meant that with an implicit "... unless the license-seeker is willing to expend considerably more effort." Of course we could also be talking about some technological components, such as an insurance-style OBD box you plug in for the duration of your learning period, that submits you to a more extensive evaluation if you're detected to be driving aggressively or whatever.
- giantg2 5y agoI don't really like the OBD boxes. They have to use GPS to be effective. Even then, it's mostly about speed and misses other things. There could be scenarios where rapid speed changes are prudent. I don't want to be penalized for slamming on the brakes if a deer jumps our in front of me just because the sensor registers a rapid deceleration.
- mikepurvis 5y agoFair, yeah— it's not really a super thought-through suggestion. More just saying that we have 25 years of technological change in the space since graduated licensing was introduced in the 90s, and that alone is probably reason to revisit the whole thing.
- frenchy 5y ago> We can fly ultralights without a license. Not over a city, also, how many pedestrians to ultralights kill anually? Generally people are not greatly bothered by someone engaging in solo risky behavior in the middle of nowhere. > I think most people are capable of safely operating a car. Great, now if we could just figure out who those people are and get the rest of them off the road, that would be amazing, but as it currently stands, car drivers are regularly killing people.
- giantg2 5y ago"Great, now if we could just figure out who those people are and get the rest of them off the road, that would be amazing, but as it currently stands, car drivers are regularly killing people." What's your point; or is this just a rant ignoring my comments on increasing testing?