4 ms·
I’m not defending them, but that’s really an unfair assessment. They are tweaking the model for how the cold storage tier is priced, with some minor reductions
by Spooky23 5y ago
I’m not defending them, but that’s really an unfair assessment. They are tweaking the model for how the cold storage tier is priced, with some minor reductions on the storage component and price increases on the “operational”/tasking side.
I haven’t managed a hyper cloud service, but I have managed 7-8 figure enterprise services. Sometimes as a service and ecosystem evolves, you need to tweak the business model. For a service like this, I would guess a set of customers stumbled into or found some loopholes that affected the economics of the services.
It is still a simpler model than Glacier, which is the AWS service closest to this.
As a customer, supplier risk is always something to factor. You can’t be religious about tech stacks for this reason and always need to chase dollars. If you have the market power, sometimes you can delay these sorts of actions with termed price contracts. If you don’t have lots of compliance requirements, paying for them baked into GCP may not be a good idea!
If your business (or bonus) is dependent on the beneficence of AWS, Azure, GCP, etc, you need to make sure that you understand that you are rolling the dice and someday the happy times will end.
- xyzzy123 5y agoAFAIK AWS have never increased prices on any specific product offering. Your overall point still stands, agree you have to have a plan for the day your vendor decides to put the squeeze on (and that can take many forms).
- Graphguy 5y agoI’m fairly confident they usually raise prices through new generations of compute instances.
- chockchocschoir 5y agoThat's like saying Apple raises the prices of the iPhone through new generation of iPhone models, which is not true at all. If the same service gets a higher price, then it's a praise raise. If a new service gets a higher price, it's just a new service.
- remus 5y ago> That's like saying Apple raises the prices of the iPhone through new generation of iPhone models, which is not true at all. If the same service gets a higher price, then it's a praise raise. If a new service gets a higher price, it's just a new service. I don't think the distinction is that clear: you could just rebrand an existing service and raise the price. "Try our new v2 APIs, guaranteed compatibility with our v1 API and only 10% more expensive!" I think the reality is somewhere in between, where companies will use new product launches to add stuff for customers and raise prices to protect their margin.
- Spooky23 5y agoApple margins are pretty consistent. Assuming the assumption that intergenerational go up is true, in general compute only gets cheaper over time, so escalating prices implies increasing margin.
- oblio 5y ago> That's like saying Apple raises the prices of the iPhone through new generation of iPhone models, which is not true at all. I don't know if I'm reading your comment right, but the average selling price of iPhones has been climbing steadily from the start.
- sciurus 5y agoIt's actually the opposite! To pick a representative example Current generation: m6i.large: $0.0960 m6a.large: $0.0864 m6g.large: $0.0770 Previous generations: m5.large: $0.0960 m4.large: $0.1000 m3.large: $0.1330 m1.large: $0.1750
- la64710 5y ago
- Graphguy 5y agohttps://rbranson.medium.com/rds-pricing-has-more-than-doubled-ef8c3b7e5218 https://rbranson.medium.com/rds-pricing-has-more-than-double... is a good example of using the generation abstraction to improve margins. Obviously, this source is not a price increase. It’s just increase in premium over EC2. https://redmonk.com/rstephens/2021/12/17/iaas-pricing-2021/ https://redmonk.com/rstephens/2021/12/17/iaas-pricing-2021/ Is also great and shows a flatness in price
- chrisandchris 5y agoThey also don't discontinue any service as long as at least 1 customer* uses it. Which means: you will have the old (in your opinion probably lower) price forever, as long as you don't upgrade. That's a very important distinction: increasing prices for users who can't go away and increased prices for users which migrate on their own to the new pricing structure. As far as I know, Google does the former which always has a "fader Beigeschmack" (DE; dulm aftertaste?) IMHO. * = whatever that means :)
- _puk 5y ago"We are reaching out to inform you that we will be retiring EC2-Classic on August 15, 2022. This message contains important information about the retirement and steps to take before the retirement date How does this impact you? Your AWS account currently has EC2-Classic enabled for EU-WEST-1 Region".. To be fair, "EC2-Classic is a flat network that we launched with EC2 in the summer of 2006", so I'm not complaining, but thought it was an interesting counterpoint.
- deanCommie 5y agoIt's not a counterpoint, though. They're retiring a product that's been deprecated for half a decade. No prices are being raised... edit: I misunderstood, I thought we were still talking about prices.
- alasdair_ 5y agoThe GP said “ They also don't discontinue any service as long as at least 1 customer* uses it.” The person you are replying to gave the counterpoint that AWS is discontinuing a service that the person is currently using. This seems like a valid counterpoint to me.
- nl 5y agoI thought that at the time I got that notification. But it turns out I don't have any EC2-Classic instances, and was really just a notification I wouldn't be able to create new one.
- ec109685 5y agoThat could also mean that AWS bakes in incredible margin, so they can absorb underlying component price increases without going upside down on margin.
- SahAssar 5y agoAgreed, but in that case every AWS offering should always be more expensive, right? Is that the case?
- joebob42 5y agoProbably not literally, but in my experience the answer is more or less just "yes, aws is more expensive than competitors"
- LoveGracePeace 5y agoThis is not my experience with AWS, not at all. AWS deserves huge praise for this.
- jeffparsons 5y agoThat's fine, because as a business I can decide whether or not that price is acceptable to me. On the other hand, if they are known to occasionally significantly increase the price of their offering, then I have to factor that risk into my budget (let's face it: most businesses are locked in to their current cloud provider to a significant extent) so the price on the label is misleading. I much prefer to pay a bit more up front than to have to constantly guesstimate how much financial risk is introduced by my cloud provider's erratic business decisions.
- Spooky23 5y agoI don’t follow AWS pricing closely enough to comment. But I would say that the AWS glacier pricing model is/was… inscrutable to say the least. There’s probably a reason for that! :)
- idunno246 5y agoIt’s not never, but it’s rare. They renamed to cloud map and took a free product and started charging for it https://mobile.twitter.com/0xdabbad00/status/1068197705594228736 https://mobile.twitter.com/0xdabbad00/status/106819770559422...
- adrianlmm 5y ago>I’m not defending them yes you are.
- blip54321 5y agoOP has a fair assessment. It's an unfair defense. Whenever I've relied on Google, I eventually got !@#$%. I've never had that problem with Amazon. Microsoft also doesn't do it much these days. This is really specific to Google (and Oracle; but Oracle !@#$% in the wallet, but at least realizes driving customers out-of-business is bad for business). Not all GCP customers will be !@#$% here, but many will. People who rely on Google inevitably regret it at some point.
- Spooky23 5y agoThey will all let you down. If you think you aren’t getting screwed by Microsoft, you either don’t do a lot of business with them or aren’t paying attention. Oracle gets the reputation, but Microsoft probably liberates more bullshit dollars from companies than anyone else. They are like taxes, minus deductions.