3 ms·
Ontology Is Overrated (2005)
- PaulHoule 5y agoWow, this article keeps coming back. At the time "tagging" implementations at sites like Flickr and Danbooru looked pretty fresh but in 2022 they seem as much part of the problem as the solution. I remember doing some medium-scale crawling against Flickr (millions of images) and found all kinds of anomalies in tagging like the guy who took 3000 pictures at a wedding and tagged them all "rat". What's ironic about it is that, like almost everybody outside the semantic web cult, the author gets the idea of the semantic web 100% backwards insofar as the whole point of RDFS and OWL is that I can write vernacular:termInPoorlyDesignedOntology rdfs:subPropertyOf my:termInFitForPurposeOntology . and map terms in other people's vocabularies into terms that are meaningful to me. The semantic web wasn't an effort to get people to write facts in a standardized vocabulary as to provide tools for mashing up what people write to what is useful. The trouble is that people outside the community never acknowledged that this was the intention, and people inside the community never acknowledged that standards like RDFS and OWL were inadequate to the task. (No ability to change the shape of data in complex ways, no ability to do simple math to convert Fahrenheit to Centigrade, no ability to clean out bad facts, etc.)