3 ms·
My point is that this is a basic dynamic that exists in biology as well (or any ecosystem). If you have extreme monoculture, specialists can and will flourish.
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
My point is that this is a basic dynamic that exists in biology as well (or any ecosystem). If you have extreme monoculture, specialists can and will flourish. Specialization as a strategy is much less effective in a diverse ecosystem. If you target one algorithm successfully, the others will work better as a result; and vice versa. It's fairly easy to construct mutually incompatible scoring systems. Even minor differences in scoring will limit the success of specialization.
It doesn't matter if it's a search engine or half a continent growing nothing but wheat, the dynamic is the same.
- samhw 5y agoSorry for the late reply - and thank you for responding! That makes perfect sense. I share your thought about this. I hope my comment wasn’t too unclear. I was just considering that a more diverse ecosystem of algorithms doesn’t necessarily imply a more diverse ecosystem of companies. Hence my thought experiment about a marketplace of algorithms within one search provider. But of course I’m not wedded to that, and I have no reason to be. Both situations seem equally improbable to me: (a) Google’s losing dominance, or (b) Google’s providing a marketplace of different algorithms. I’d be interested to hear any more thoughts you might have! Thanks again for your reply.