5 ms·
Git isn't what attracts most people to GitHub I disagree (partly). GitHub is indeed a sort of social-network for developers working on open-source projects, a
by bad_user 15y ago
Git isn't what attracts most people to GitHub
I disagree (partly).
GitHub is indeed a sort of social-network for developers working on open-source projects, and this makes it really attractive. Their interface is also totally kick-ass and I love them.
But for my private projects GitHub is totally useless and also expensive, which is why I have been hosting my own Git repo on an instance that I own - it's pretty easy to setup too.
I am very excited that Bitbucket is offering Git as an option, as Mercurial for me is not really compelling; not that Git is necessarily better but it's what I know and have absolutely no reason to learn yet-another-tool-that-does-the-same-thing.
- skrebbel 15y agoOpposite for me. I never really knew whether to choose Mercurial, Bzr or Git and ended up using Git for everything because of Github.
- trebor 15y ago> But for my private projects GitHub is totally useless and also expensive, which is why I have been hosting my own Git repo on an instance that I own - it's pretty easy to setup too. Ditto. There's a number of projects that I just won't put online because I'd rather lose than share them. With Bitbucket it looks like I'll be able to stash them privately, for free. I'm totally psyched that Bitbucket has given this good a plan as their base/free package.
- vog 15y ago> There's a number of projects that I just won't put online because I'd rather lose than share them. Assuming that those projects don't generate much revenue for you [1], what's the point of keeping them private? From a political point of view, I always see such projects as a good opportunity to promote Free Software. From an economic point of view, I like to put some pressure on my competitors that way. For really valuable stuff, I'm using strict licenses like GPLv3 or AGPLv3 which ensure that sharing won't result in any disadvantage for me. So I really wonder (as a seriously meant question!) what kind of projects you are talking about. What kind of non/small-revenue project would anyone rather lose than share? [1] Otherwise I'd wonder why you couldn't afford paying GitHub, and also couldn't afford to switch to Mercurial for hosting them on BitBucket for free.
- TreesCanCode 15y agoNot poster but in a similar position myself. What about incomplete projects? Messy/hacky experiments? Completely idiotic/backwards stuff done for fun? Play-projects purely attempted for "ha I did it!"? Legally-grey (or blatantly illegal) projects? Or even school projects? I have hundreds of projects that fit in those categories, and none will ever be made publicly available. Sometimes it's just not good form to make a project public, other times it's clearly harmful to do so. Nevertheless, I preserve my projects privately just in case I ever resume work on a whim, or want to reference what I did in the past (or more likely, what I did wrong). And now I can put them online privately for free, sharing with those I deem appropriate.
- vog 15y ago> incomplete projects? It depends on what you mean by "incomplete". 50 lines of code which do almost nothing useful are probably not worth publishing. But why not publishing a half-complete project? Publishing may help you find contributors. And the early feedback helps you to decide if your project is worth more intense attention. > Messy/hacky experiments? If the code is not too bad, I publish even that stuff (as long as it is big enough to be notable), e.g. http://pypi.python.org/pypi/vserver http://pypi.python.org/pypi/vserver > Completely idiotic/backwards stuff done for fun? I recently published such a project and got surprisingly great feedback: http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3061050 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3061050 > Play-projects purely attempted for "ha I did it!"? Why not? You never know who'll like it anyway, e.g. http://sourceforge.net/projects/hosh/ http://sourceforge.net/projects/hosh/ > Legally-grey (or blatantly illegal) projects? Depending on how much trouble this might cause, you probably shouldn't upload it anywhere. Even a "private" repository on GitHub/BitBucket might be too risky. On the other hand, I know about a Free Software clone of a game that used the original graphics and music. Not quite legal, but the game was very old and the right holders obviously didn't care. However, after publishing the project got a little fan base that eventually included graphic designers and musicians, who replaced the proprietary stuff step by step with their own creations. So the game changed from "legally-grey" to "solid free". This would never have been possible if the game hadn't been published. > Or even school projects? My school projects were about the first ones I published, and I'm pretty proud about what I wrote in that age, e.g. http://davis.sf.net/ http://davis.sf.net/ http://sourceforge.net/projects/voji/ http://sourceforge.net/projects/voji/ http://sourceforge.net/projects/volt/ http://sourceforge.net/projects/volt/ Later I also published some notable university project works (sorry, German language): http://www.profv.de/uni/ http://www.profv.de/uni/ However, these are only project works. I will never publish specific solutions to homework excercises, as this would only help cheaters and nobody else.
- pyre 15y ago> I'd rather lose than share them You don't have a backup system?
- trebor 15y agoI have a backup system. It's just that I'd rather lose them than share them—exactly how I said it.