4 ms·
> . People would just abuse the system, using highly capitalist, low tax countries during their youth and move to socialist countries as they as getting older (
by toast0 5y ago
> . People would just abuse the system, using highly capitalist, low tax countries during their youth and move to socialist countries as they as getting older (of course that does not work, you need borders for this) and it's utterly unfair to let people from outside abuse a contributive system.
The United States is kind of a micro example. Federal taxes are uniform of course, but state taxes and services are not. Retirees tend not to move to high tax, high social services spending states, they tend to do the opposite: move away from California, New York, etc to Arizona, Florida, etc to live less expensively, even if there's fewer services.
- soueuls 5y agoThe US is not a good example, your social welfare is quite limited. Spending your youth in the US accumulating capital at a rapid speed and then moving to a "socialist country" like Sweden or France and living off your investments (bonus points if your new country does not tax foreign incomes) And you can literally vampirize everyone else, abusive a contributive welfare system without really contributing much. And that's just the tip of the iceberg, many citizens don't want to live with others from specific countries at a massive scale. The world would blend too much and become vastly uninteresting.
- dagw 5y agoThe US is actually a good example, but in the opposite way. I know lots of people who moved from Scandinavia to the US in their early-mid 20s, after having finished their free university education, to earn the big money. They almost all came back when they felt it was time to have kids and start a family, so that they could enjoy free child care, parental leave and plenty of holidays.