4 ms·
Has anyone analyzed the nuclear pulse propulsion sail mentioned in the Dark Forest trilogy? The 1950's proposal was to carry nuclear explosives on a manned roc
by perihelions 5y ago
Has anyone analyzed the nuclear pulse propulsion sail mentioned in the Dark Forest trilogy? The 1950's proposal was to carry nuclear explosives on a manned rocket and throw them out the back one by one. Cixin Liu's variation, for a lightweight, one-way probe, would preposition thousands of nukes throughout the solar system, and launch a thin radiation sail on a trajectory that flies through each detonation in sequence.
I assume there's some fatal flaw to this, but it takes more domain knowledge to identify it than I'm familiar with.
- thorin1 5y agoYes, there may be some fatal flaw in taking thousands of nukes to the orbit.
- KineticLensman 5y ago> would preposition thousands of nukes throughout the solar system ... > I assume there's some fatal flaw to this It would take massive expenditure of energy to create and preposition all of those nukes. A direct contact blast (as in Project Orion) would obliterate a thin radiation sail. Radiation effects might impart a propulsive force to a more distant sail, but probably not enough to generate the sustained acceleration required. Pulsed acceleration blasts would dynamically disrupt the ultralightweight sail rigging (compared with a continuous gentle pressure from the sun or a launch laser). EMP effects might fry any electronics on an unshielded probe. [Edit] However, this idea is perhaps conceptually less completely barking than his strategy for recovering important hard drives from a defended ship passing through the Panama Canal in The Three-Body Problem. Spoiler ... ... you simply cut the ship (and crew) into tiny pieces using a nano-filament wire ambush, then recover the sliced hard drives from the sea bed and reassemble them. I basically stopped reading at that point.
- virchau13 5y agoIIRC [still spoiler] they specifically chose the spacing so that the hard drives would be unscathed, and captured the hard drives before they fell into the canal, although it is still a little ridiculous. But in any case, keep reading! I promise the rest of the book is good :)