3 ms·
It's relevant because you said: > Another request: Please argue with the facts as presented by scientist who are speaking up. And had a bit about how we can't
by ZeroGravitas 5y ago
It's relevant because you said:
> Another request: Please argue with the facts as presented by scientist who are speaking up.
And had a bit about how we can't trust politicians and need the truth.
edit to add: apparently he did PR for the Venezualan government! Ha that's even lower than I expected of him.
https://www.desmog.com/michael-shellenberger/ https://www.desmog.com/michael-shellenberger/
- robomartin 5y ago
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoOk, > Shellenberger's positions have been called "bad science" and "inaccurate" by environmental scientists and academics.[10][11][12][13][14][15][16][17][18][19] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Shellenberger https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_Shellenberger
- robomartin 5y agoI reviewed those references. Not one if them addresses the argument and claims being made here. In a nutshell: That solar and wind cannot solve climate change and are worse than nuclear across a range of criteria. You continue to argue against the man. This is meaningless. Here’s a simple example of what you could be doing instead: He claims that a solar farm that matches the output of a nuclear power plant requires 17 times more land than a large solar farm in California. Well, is this true? The math is simple. And yet, no math is necessary. https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2019/01/f58/Ultimate%20Fast%20Facts%20Guide-PRINT.pdf https://www.energy.gov/sites/prod/files/2019/01/f58/Ultimate... Quoting: “A typical 1,000-megawatt nuclear facility in the United States needs a little more than 1 square mile to operate. NEI says wind farms require 360 times more land area to produce the same amount of electricity and solar photovoltaic plants require 75 times more space.” That’s how you analyze a claim if your objective is to ascertain the validity and soundness of the argument. Once again, attacking the man (or irrelevant statements) is pointless.
- robomartin 5y agoI should add to this that attacking the person instead of the argument is, sadly, something that is all too common today and possibly exacerbated by the Pavlovian reactions of the unthinking masses in social media. It is far easier to attack the person than to do the sometimes difficult work involved in truly evaluating what they might be proposing. This is a particularly cruel and unfair fallacy as well. What it means is that if a person makes a mistake someone can put their finger on nothing that person says or does ever in their entire lives will be deemed worthy of evaluation. Everything they do or say from that point forward is false, invalid, wrong, not acceptable. Why? Because of who they are. That is not a society of which anyone would want to be a part. Anyone who has ever made a mistake or said something wrong in life should be able to understand just how wrong it is to look at the world in this manner. Not one human being on this planet can claim not having been wrong one or, more than likely, hundreds, if not thousands of times. This is why in Logic we are taught that arguments have be be evaluated for correctness and soundness (two different things) without any regard for the source.
- elahieh 5y agoShellenberger RE land use claims debunked, assuming good faith just once. After that, the experts get tired and cite Brandolini's Law. https://twitter.com/simonahac/status/1446605374119759873 https://twitter.com/simonahac/status/1446605374119759873
- robomartin 5y agoSorry to put it this way, I just have to. The argument that guy is making on Twitter is pure horseshit. This is the problem, people don't want to do the math and choose to rely on personalities to tell them what to believe. It's also a dishonest Twitter hit-and-run. Read my longer post where I try to make sense of the claim about solar requiring hundreds more land than nuclear. That's a good approximation of the kind of honest scientific work you have to do to evaluate these claims, not the bullshit floating around on social media. In other words, as they say in math class: Show me the work. There's so much people ignore about solar it makes my head hurt. And, on top of that, most people speak without having any experience or "skin in the game". I built a 13 kW ground-mount solar array on my property. From scratch. To be clear, that means, I designed every element of it, put it through the permit process, and built the entire thing with my own two hands (well, my kids helped!). Here's a data point: My microscopic 13 kW array required 64 THOUSAND pounds of concrete. Yup. That is what Los Angeles County had me install as a footing for this thing. I fought them as hard as I could. I lost. Eight columns, 8000 lbs of concrete and hundreds of pounds of rebar holding them down. An architect friend of mine told me you could put up a four level building on that footing. On commercial installations, they add massive amounts of steel to this to build the structure. I have no way to evaluate this at all, but I would not be surprised if a large scale photovoltaic facility required more concrete and steel than the equivalent power nuclear power plant. Again, just a guess. It would be interesting to dig-up records for something like Diablo Canyon nuclear power plant and make the comparison.