3 ms·
"I could see a good argument for making an ivy league school with an enrollment of 100k, simply to break the ivy league elitist bullshit." The elitists would s
by giantg2 5y ago
"I could see a good argument for making an ivy league school with an enrollment of 100k, simply to break the ivy league elitist bullshit."
The elitists would simply view that larger school as inferior.
- sokoloff 5y agoI think they'd not be entirely incorrect in that view. No school will grow 7x-20x and maintain the same standards in admissions, in education, or in alumni achievement per-capita. They'd instantly become the Ivy League Safety School, which would deter many of the strongest future applicants from applying and deter many of their strong admits from choosing that school if they had multiple Ivy admittances.
- giantg2 5y agoIs the quality of education really better? My understanding is it's all just selection or an IQ test - strongest apply, strongest get in, places hire them based on the prestige of the name.
- wallscratch 5y agoAs someone who went to a state school for undergrad and an ivy for phd (and took some undergrad cs classes there), and I can say that yes, the undergraduate classes are definitely much harder at ivy league schools, at least in stem.
- wolverine876 5y ago> Is the quality of education really better? My understanding is it's all just selection or an IQ test - strongest apply, strongest get in, places hire them based on the prestige of the name. What is your understanding based on?
- sokoloff 5y agoIt’s been studied. > For most students, the salary boost from going to a super-selective school is “generally indistinguishable from zero” after adjusting for student characteristics, such as test scores. In other words, if Mike and Drew have the same SAT scores and apply to the same colleges, but Mike gets into Harvard and Drew doesn’t, they can still expect to earn the same income throughout their careers. Despite Harvard’s international fame and energetic alumni outreach, somebody like Mike would not experience an observable “Harvard effect.” Dale and Krueger even found that the average SAT scores of all the schools a student applies to is a more powerful predictor of success than the school that student actually attends. https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2018/12/does-it-matter-where-you-go-college/577816/ https://www.theatlantic.com/ideas/archive/2018/12/does-it-ma... That’s not “education” directly, but does suggest an extremely strong applicant pool selection effect is happening.
- wolverine876 5y ago> "... if Mike and Drew have the same SAT scores and apply to the same colleges, but Mike gets into Harvard and Drew doesn’t, they can still expect to earn the same income throughout their careers ..." That is interesting and surprises me: Certainly many elite jobs are available to Harvard graduates that aren't available to most others. I wonder how that fact (AFAICT) reconciles with the claim about income. > That’s not “education” directly Agreed - the market doesn't reward education, but how well you serve their particular corporate needs. Education isn't vocational training, especially at better schools.
- sokoloff 5y agoEven if that is the sole and exclusive source of the prestige*, I think that effect would persist among the 7 Ivy League schools who didn't turn themself into a safety school, because the "strongest get in" effect would be strongest at those 7. I do think education differences would also occur. It's simply not possible to scale undergraduate lectures, recitation, labs, lecture and small group spaces, etc, by a factor of 7-20x and keep the same quality. (At a minimum, it's not possible to do so quickly/in a single step.) * I think it's a majority of the source of their prestige, but not exclusive.
- wolverine876 5y ago> The elitists would simply view that larger school as inferior. The OP says Columbia is growing rapidly, yet there has been no such reaction. Who are these "elitists"? Can you cite such a reaction?
- giantg2 5y agoGrowing rapidly and still no where near a big school. The article even states that with the growth it's not that much bigger than the smallest ivy league as viewed through the context of comparing all schools.
- wolverine876 5y agoOK, but where is evidence of the reaction you claim happens or would happen?
- giantg2 5y agoDo you have any evidence of prestige not dropping with increase in size or lower selectability? Can you name a large Ivy League? This seems to hint at the idea that larger institutions are not as prestigious: "A serious loss of prestige for French universities : in spite of their 12% of foreign students (rank 2 in Europe after UK) , the French universities no longer attract the best students from the whole world; the recent ranking made by the University of Shanghai of the 500 best universities of the world is awful for the French national pride (the best one ranks 65th) : the good teaching and research centers are too small, and the big universities are not good enough ;" http://www.understandfrance.org/France/Education.html http://www.understandfrance.org/France/Education.html
- wolverine876 5y ago> Do you have any evidence of prestige not dropping with increase in size or lower selectability? You made the claim, so it is up to you to prove it.