4 ms·
> Would you be fine if someone described the troubles in Northern Ireland as ethnic tension Why not? It's a lot more accurate than the usual description of "Pr
by zozbot234 5y ago
> Would you be fine if someone described the troubles in Northern Ireland as ethnic tension
Why not? It's a lot more accurate than the usual description of "Protestants and Catholics" while still being simple and clear.
- notahacker 5y agoYep, that's the counter argument right there. Sometimes it's better to be vaguely accurate than precisely missing much of the point.
- Retric 5y agoVaguely accurate is just another way of saying wrong.
- notahacker 5y agoNo, "vaguely accurate" is a way of avoiding labels which are more precise and wrong. It's better to describe a disputed large quantity with the vague but accurate label of "millions" than choose a random scholar of unknown quality's estimate to 3 s.f as the correct figure. It's better to summarise the Troubles in Northern Ireland vaguely accurately as "ethnic tensions" than precisely wrongly as a religious war between two schools of Christianity.
- Retric 5y agoSaying gas is about 4$ right now is vaguely accurate, of course it’s also wrong. Consider the phrase “not even vaguely accurate” means it’s not just wrong it’s very wrong. Being vaguely accurate on a history test may give partial credit, but the news should to be held to a higher standard.
- Retric 5y ago> Why not? Because it wasn’t purely ethnic in nature with Protestants and Catholics on both sides of the conflict. Trying to summarize it as ethic conflict was therefore also also incorrect. Which why using ethic tensions is so often misleading, it seems appropriate in many situations when it really isn’t.