4 ms·
>Some countries excel at financial services, others at manufacturing, still others at providing natural resources. I think this could reasonably be considered
by Ekaros 5y ago
>Some countries excel at financial services, others at manufacturing, still others at providing natural resources.
I think this could reasonably be considered as a racist take. There is nothing inherently in financial services that should make any country better at it. Reasonably it is all about first mover advantage, incupetentcy and lower regulatory environment allowing possibly harmful actions.
I wonder if we see the model failing eventually in future, or will the current winners focus even harder to keep anyone new down just so they can extract wealth in an other way than imperialism...
- lanternfish 5y agoYou can make a serious of arguments about how the nature of industry in a country ultimately derives from historical and geological factors which can be causally divorced from genetic traits. I don't think any critical theorists would consider the statement 'industrial comparative advantages exist across countries' to be racist - or even something like neo-imperialist. You could claim that capitalism is flawed due to the way it distributes labor against these historical differences (many of which were propogated along racial lines due to colonialism), but I don't think the analytical claim _under_ capitalism holds any normative merit.
- stormbrew 5y agoCapitalism was built on these racist systems like colonialism and chattel slavery. You can try to separate them, but fundamentally the GP is entirely right that the reason financial services are "suited" to britain is because of centuries of brutal exploitation of countries that are "suited" to resource extraction. Neither of these things are inherently true of the people or the places, they are direct consequences of particular political structures and violent intervention. In the end, it's extremely profitable under capitalism for some people to be considered sub-human. That's not an accident, it's the game. Capitalism has never existed independent of this premise.
- zozbot234 5y ago> Capitalism was built on these racist systems like colonialism and chattel slavery ... centuries of brutal exploitation of countries that are "suited" to resource extraction. Daron Acemoglu's Why Nations Fail handily disproves that argument. Latin America, and Spanish colonization in general, was built on those exact same things to a far greater extent and for a longer span of time; and today it is, by and large, a thoroughly anti-capitalist economic basket-case. The two are only loosely related to each other, and the correlation might easily be in the negative.
- stormbrew 5y agoMaybe it does but if so you haven't conveyed it very well. Are you arguing that Latin America is not exploited for its resources under the global system of capitalism? Because that's a pretty absurd position to take. You might even imagine how that exploitation could lead to revolutionary politics and the current state of affairs there. But even if we take that as a given, "it didn't work uniformly in all directions in the same way" is not an argument that the relationship doesn't exist. My assertion is that capitalism has always coexisted with systems that treat some people as sub-human, so can't be completely disentangled from them. You're going to have to work a lot harder to "disprove that argument," imo.
- zozbot234 5y agoThe earlier comment in this thread was arguing that "the global system of capitalism" could explain why Britain and its colonies are uniquely suited to providing highly-developed financial services. Now you're saying that the same "global system of capitalism" explains extractive systems in Latin American colonies. These are polar opposites in terms of outcomes, how can they possibly be explained by the same factor? Why Nations Fail tackles the same stylized facts in a far more nuanced manner, examining local policy choices (often exploitive ones) as often more relevant than fuzzy global "systems".
- stormbrew 5y ago
- simonh 5y agoIt’s mostly about history, regulatory climate, sunk investments, institutions and skills. Nothing to do with race.
- s1artibartfast 5y ago>I think this could reasonably be considered as a racist take. Nonsense. Nobody is claiming the cause is racial. There are real world situations that make some countries more attractive to financial services. This doesn't mean they are immutable and can not change.